Hi JAW,
Is it OK for me to post here? This forum is new to me so I don't want to be breaking any rules.
Hopefully I can help explain the reasoning behind the Blue Note XRCDs, just released this week.
First of all, understand that I take the privilege of having access to the original Blue Note master tapes VERY seriously. I've loved Blue Note for as long as I can remember. When EMI and Michael Cuscuna gave Ron Rambach and I carte blanche to create the ultimate LP reissues of Blue Note titles two years ago, we dove into it 24/7 with all of our hearts! It’s a project that continues to this day. I've had the pleasure of working with many of the great analog mastering engineers over the years. For this particular project, the choice of Steve Hoffman and Kevin Grey at Acoustech Mastering was a natural, especially considering the fact that mastering at Acoustech allows you to take your acetate directly over to plating at RTI. That's a serious advantage!
In early 2009, when the opportunity to have the same access to Blue Note masters was presented from a digital perspective, I again thought through all options carefully. I have extensive experience with SACD, having produced over 50 titles for various labels on SACD. I was creative director for the JVC/XRCD program for a number of years as well. My choice of Alan Yoshida (OceanWay Mastering) and XRCD was based on only one thing.....which mastering engineer and what chain, would provide the results that I would personally want to hear? How would I want the ideal digital presentation of Blue Note to be produced?
That was the reasoning. The results have just been released for those who are interested to listen to (and look at since these are presented as bound books with added session photos.) I'll be very curious to read impressions from those of you who buy these.
I hope you enjoy them as much as I am this evening!
Cheers,
Joe
But the projects are at least partly about the same Blue Note titles. Hoffman mastered them for 45rpm LP release for Harley's Music Matters label previously.
http://www.musicmattersjazz.com/titles.html
So Harley hired Hoffman to master LPs, and then a couple of months later he hires Yoshida to master the same titles for CD. This looks like unnecessary duplication of work to me, compared to the Analogue Productions way to do it for ther LP and SACD reissues
http://www.stevehoffman.tv/forums/showpost...mp;postcount=11
Why not ask Joe Harley about "the how and the why"?