Jump to content

danasgoodstuff

Members
  • Posts

    4,525
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Donations

    0.00 USD 

Posts posted by danasgoodstuff

  1. On 3/26/2024 at 5:23 AM, John L said:

    Well, they were saying the exact same thing in the 60s - that rock music was less complex and a watering down of Tin Pan Alley-based pop.  

    I think that a basic important point here is that complexity in music is hard to measure.  It depends on the measuring rod that is being used.  If we are looking only at harmonic complexity, for example, then it looks like popular music has become increasingly less complex since the mid-20th century.  If we measure by rhythmic complexity, we will get a different result.  

    And, or course, we could also argue about the relationship between complexity and quality in music. 

    Yes, it's ironic that most of these 'the world is dumbing down' narratives are themselves quite simplistic and naive. 

  2. Atlantic recorded some classic New Orleans players in the '50s.  I have some but not all.  Henry Red Allen made some very nice albums in the late '50s and early '60s, but although his roots in New Orleans were deep (his father ran a brass band in the 19th century) these are not strictly traditional in approach.  I'm particularly fond of Ride Red Ride on RCA with Coleman Hawkins as a sideman.

  3. 4 hours ago, JSngry said:

    If the Delphonics count, then so do The Stylistics:

    Both are really good songs. 

    Grant Green also did Betcha by Golly Wow and Freddie and Bobby Hutcherson each did nice renditions of People Make the World Go Round

    Ray Charles rendition of One Mint julep is probably the best remembered now, but Freddie did it before that and the Clovers did it first, so I think it's squarely within this topic.

  4. 7 minutes ago, Rabshakeh said:

    I should add that what I was particularly thinking of when starting this thread was groups with multiple horns playing the doo wop arrangements, not just the central melody. It's even harder to think of those.

    Yes, I was disappointed the WSQ didn't do that on their R&B album, just take the voices directly from vocal group performances and transfer them to the horns.

    Bill Frisell et al doing the Delphonics' La La La La La La Means I Love You, I love this but as far as I know there's no official hard copy product.  I think this was the final tune of an otherwise fairly standard (for them) set list.

  5. 4 hours ago, Rabshakeh said:
    4 hours ago, danasgoodstuff said:

    John Patton/Grant Green/Bill Dixon

    Did they work for others? 

    Yes, Lou Donaldson, Don Wilkerson, also Patton albums with and without added horns.

    4 hours ago, Rabshakeh said:

    "The Rhythm Section" of pianist Red Garland, bassist Paul Chambers and drummer Philly Joe Jones. The piano trio from Miles Davis' First Quintet, which was then hired out for various other dates, most noticably the Art Pepper one.

    Yes, but the Red Garland trio albums on Prestige had Art Taylor drumming instead of Philly Joe.

  6. Since I was having technical difficulties, Felser kindly offered to help me get a track posted.  So, I sent them a list to pick from:

    Fish Scale (youtube.com) David Grisman Quintet, Fish Scale

    All The Way (youtube.com) King Curtis, All the Way

    The Wind Cries Mary (youtube.com) Geri Allen & the Batson Brothers, The Wind Cries Mary from 3 Pianos For Jimi

    I Got It Bad (And That Ain't Good) (youtube.com) Red Garland, I Got It Bad from Red Alone

    J. Zorn, B. Frisell, G. Lewis - 11. Ole (More News For Lulu, 1992) (youtube.com) 

    and they picked the Geri Allen track as one they could do.  It happened to be the most recent one (1998).  The three pianos don't necessarily all play at once all the time.  This is not necessarily my favorite track, but the others I liked were longer.  I'm glad people liked it.  I've been aware of Ms. Allen's work since near the start of her career, although I didn't always follow it as closely as I might have.  Her early demise was a great loss.  I don't know much else about the Batson Brothers besides their work here.

  7. 2 hours ago, monkboughtlunch said:

    Who recorded them?

    The writer isn't wrong.  😀 The whistle on the 1975 Oil Can Harry's date is cringeworthy.  

    In fact, it would be a perfect use case for modern de-mixing technology.  Digitally remove the whistle on two-track pre-FM mix-downs of live Grant Green recordings.  It would be kind of a public service -- like removing Yoko Ono screaming over John Lennon and Chuck Berry on the Dick Cavett Show.  😁

    I don't think either of those would be a legit use of de-mixing, they meant to do that whether you like it or not.  Just as taking the electric saw off that one track on Lee Morgan's last album was bogus, regardless of how you feel about musical saws.  However, it would be legit to take the screaming idiot in the audience off of Elvis C at the Elmo.

  8. 18 hours ago, AllenLowe said:

    there is a whole book somewhere of jazz-types experimenting with long forms in those days, but unfortunately I have forgotten the title; but check out Nat Shilkret, who was interesting:

    https://www.amazon.com/Symphonic-Jazz-Carpenter/dp/B00006RHPG

     

    here's the book:

    https://www.amazon.com/Ellington-Uptown-Johnson-Concert-Perspectives/dp/0472033166/ref=sr_1_1?crid=1X6WL3K7X58V3&keywords=ellington+uptown&qid=1706839470&s=books&sprefix=ellington+uptown%2Cstripbooks%2C71&sr=1-1

    Thanks, I'll have to check that out.  I was thinking more that someone in the Porter/Arlen/Rodgers axis had tried their hand a longform composition, but I could be mis-remembering.

×
×
  • Create New...