Jump to content

1965 Downbeat Reader's Poll Best Organist


Soul Stream

Recommended Posts

Place Votes

1. Jimmy Smith 3705

2. Shirley Scott 488

3. Jack McDuff 185

4. Wild Bill Davis 154

5. Clare Fischer (wtf?) 154

6. Count Basie (?) 119

7. Larry Young 112

8. Don Patterson 86

9. Groove Holmes 68

10. Freddie Roach 56

11. Ray Charles (?) 50

12. Jimmy McGriff 39

13. Mel Rhyne 39

14. Joe Mooney (wtf?) 37

15. Earl Grant 36

16. John Patton 36

Pretty interesting. According to the magazine, Larry Young, Don Patterson, Jimmy McGriff, Mel Rhyne and John Patton had never even been in the top results until that year!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 94
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Place Votes

6. Count Basie (?) 119

Wasn't this about the time that Basie made an album for Impulse with him on organ? Not that it explains such a high spot in the rankings, but those yearly polls can be unduly responsive to short-term influences (I wonder if he was even on the list for the previous two years or the two years following, give or take).

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Well, if you think about it...Larry Young put out UNITY in 1965 and placed 2 spots behind Clare Fischer for chissakes! So, I'm not surprised John placed so low. As a matter of fact, previously I had heard he had never placed in a Downbeat poll....so, I'm not sure if he ever placed again or if I was misinformed.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Well, if you think about it...Larry Young put out UNITY in 1965 and placed 2 spots behind Clare Fischer for chissakes! So, I'm not surprised John placed so low. As a matter of fact, previously I had heard he had never placed in a Downbeat poll....so, I'm not sure if he ever placed again or if I was misinformed.

Unity was RECORDED in 1965, but I'm guessing it didn't come out until 1966. So I doubt any of the readers had heard it.

Guy

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Well, if you think about it...Larry Young put out UNITY in 1965 and placed 2 spots behind Clare Fischer for chissakes! So, I'm not surprised John placed so low. As a matter of fact, previously I had heard he had never placed in a Downbeat poll....so, I'm not sure if he ever placed again or if I was misinformed.

Unity was RECORDED in 1965, but I'm guessing it didn't come out until 1966. So I doubt any of the readers had heard it.

Guy

Just pulled my 'Unity' vinyl out and I think you're right - it has a '37-66' anniversary inner sleeve for a 1966 issue.

I guess 'Into Somethin' would have been out in 1965.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Those 36 guys who voted for John Patton back in 1965 must have been really cool cats! :g

Everybody not voting for Smith was a cool cat back then!

p.s. Clare Fischer is a very good organist IMHO - he's pretty off mainstream as far as his registrations etc. are concerned. I still have to get me a copy of So Danco Samba, but his playing on Manteca and the Tjader LPs is very hip.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Those 36 guys who voted for John Patton back in 1965 must have been really cool cats! :g

Everybody not voting for Smith was a cool cat back then!

p.s. Clare Fischer is a very good organist IMHO - he's pretty off mainstream as far as his registrations etc. are concerned. I still have to get me a copy of So Danco Samba, but his playing on Manteca and the Tjader LPs is very hip.

Clare Fischer is not an organist. He's a pianist that played organ here and there. Big difference.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

...also from my 1965 issue of Dowbeat...

...the Ad Lib section which tells what's happening in each of the major jazz cities...

Pittsburgh- Organ trios continue to be the rage among Pittsburgh's young jazz fans, who flocked to The Hurricane in early November to hear Shirley Scott with Stanley Turrentine's group followed the next week by Grant Green's group with John Patton and Ben Dixon.

....oh those were the days I guess... :D

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Those 36 guys who voted for John Patton back in 1965 must have been really cool cats! :g

Everybody not voting for Smith was a cool cat back then!

p.s. Clare Fischer is a very good organist IMHO - he's pretty off mainstream as far as his registrations etc. are concerned. I still have to get me a copy of So Danco Samba, but his playing on Manteca and the Tjader LPs is very hip.

Clare Fischer is not an organist. He's a pianist that played organ here and there. Big difference.

Admitted - but I still like his playing ... and I think for a part-time organist he's doing pretty original things on the instrument. In fact, I like him better as an organist than as a pianist - I'm not such a big fan of the Tristano school he loosely belongs to.

Edited by mikeweil
Link to comment
Share on other sites

And another thing: I don't see a problem with the majority voting for Jimmy Smith. In 1965, he was at the peak of his powers and putting out great records.

Jimmy dominated that catagory fooooorever. And rightly so. I mean the gap between number one and number two was huge for many, many years. I don't think any other single musician dominated their catagory throughout their career as much as Jimmy did.

I was actually surprised at how many votes Shirley Scott got at number two. And Jack McDuff was right in the mix too. Right on Brother Jack!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Does anybody have a 66, 67, 68, 69 or 70 readers poll? I'd like to know the results of the organists for those years. I'm curious is Patton every rose higher. Especially after albums like Let Em Roll, That Certain Feeling, Accent on the Blues and Understanding came out.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 weeks later...

Does anybody have a 66, 67, 68, 69 or 70 readers poll? I'd like to know the results of the organists for those years. I'm curious is Patton every rose higher. Especially after albums like Let Em Roll, That Certain Feeling, Accent on the Blues and Understanding came out.

The 1966 DB Readers Poll:

1- Jimmy Smith... 3,720

2- Groove Holmes...598

3- Shirley Scott... 339

4- Larry Young...308

5- Don Patterson...179

6- Jack McDuff... 168

7- Count Basie... 147

8- Wild Bill Davis... 113

9- Clare Fischer... 86

10- John Patton... 55

11- Jimmy McGriff... 48

12- Ray Charles... 47

13- Earl Grant... 42

14- Walter Wanderley... 41

15- Joe Mooney... 39

Give me time and I should be able to dig up results from the polls thru 1970 (which was the year I stopped subscribing to DB).

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.

×
×
  • Create New...