Jump to content

How Blue Note Transitioned From Mono to Stereo


Stereojack

Recommended Posts

Very interesting reading, a lot of facts I did not know. I always wondered about the March 8, 1957 date, because that would mean the Horace Silver quintet session was taped in the afternoon in Hackensack and the Jimmy Smith "Plays Pretty Just For You" session taped in the evening at Manhattan Towers. It seems to conflict with the method Rudy often stated: taking three days to set up for a remote recording. is it possible he set the remote equipment for the JOS session prior? It seems to me the same equipment he used for live club dates was the same that was used at Manhattan Towers, certainly if you look at, say the photos from Smalls for "Cool Blues" it looks like the same microphones from Manhattan Towers sessions. Also, the point made about the "Orgy in Rhythm" date being the first recorded in stereo, it seems odd that the only track recorded in mono is "Amuck".

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Anyone else notice the shoutout to our forums? "After reading this lucid and authoritative exposition, and memorizing the essential detail, you will easily be able to hold your own on the Steve Hoffman and Organisimo Forums, or post withering put-downs on any blog of your choosing (except here, careful)."

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Very informative and confirmed a lot of my suspicions. One thing that was not addressed, unless I missed it:

One of the reasons for placing the bass and piano in the center had to do with the fact that the ratio between center information vs. side information increases when you collapse a stereo signal to mono. So in such a situation, it makes sense to place the louder instruments that cut through off too the sides, and the quieter instruments that are more likely to get lost, i.e., the bass and piano, in the center. I am sure that this played a role in the thought process, in addition to the fact that bass and piano typically form the rhythmic and harmonic foundations in most jazz settings.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Anyone else notice the shoutout to our forums? "After reading this lucid and authoritative exposition, and memorizing the essential detail, you will easily be able to hold your own on the Steve Hoffman and Organisimo Forums, or post withering put-downs on any blog of your choosing (except here, careful)."

and spelled it wrong. :angry:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Very informative and confirmed a lot of my suspicions. One thing that was not addressed, unless I missed it:

One of the reasons for placing the bass and piano in the center had to do with the fact that the ratio between center information vs. side information increases when you collapse a stereo signal to mono. So in such a situation, it makes sense to place the louder instruments that cut through off too the sides, and the quieter instruments that are more likely to get lost, i.e., the bass and piano, in the center. I am sure that this played a role in the thought process, in addition to the fact that bass and piano typically form the rhythmic and harmonic foundations in most jazz settings.

Also bass is usually summed to mono below a certain frequency in stereo lacquer cutting. So maybe Van Gelder had that in mind when placing the bass in the center? I agree with the author's conclusion from the comments section that from 1959 onwards I prefer the records in stereo. And I even like stereo on some of those early transitional sessions recorded in both mono and stereo.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm not anything like an audio expert and, what I found fascinating was stuff about the relationship between RVG and Alfred.

RVG worked with loads of different producers and I wonder if anyone has looked into his relationships with Bob Weinstock, Esmond Edwards, Cal Lampley, Don Schitten and Bob Porter at Prestige; Creed Taylor in the ABC days, the Verve days and the CTI days; Herman Lubinsky (or was it always Ozzie Cadena) at Savoy; Ozzie at Choice and Prestige (Trusound) making gospel group and choir albums; Orrin Keepnews at Riverside; and others I either don't know about or have forgotten.

MG

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm not anything like an audio expert and, what I found fascinating was stuff about the relationship between RVG and Alfred.

RVG worked with loads of different producers and I wonder if anyone has looked into his relationships with Bob Weinstock, Esmond Edwards, Cal Lampley, Don Schitten and Bob Porter at Prestige; Creed Taylor in the ABC days, the Verve days and the CTI days; Herman Lubinsky (or was it always Ozzie Cadena) at Savoy; Ozzie at Choice and Prestige (Trusound) making gospel group and choir albums; Orrin Keepnews at Riverside; and others I either don't know about or have forgotten.

MG

Plus Bob Thiele with Impulse.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Whatever happened to that guy who was doing what he called the RVG project? He appeared very briefly either here or on the BNBB; sounded like he had people working with him, too.

That was Dan Skea, and I don't really know what became of the RVG project. He did publish an article on RVG a number of years back:

http://jazzstudiesonline.org/files/jso/resources/pdf/RudyVanGelder.pdf

I seem to recall that the RVG project had some fairly lofty ambitions behind it... I'd love to know what's happened with it.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm not anything like an audio expert and, what I found fascinating was stuff about the relationship between RVG and Alfred.

RVG worked with loads of different producers and I wonder if anyone has looked into his relationships with Bob Weinstock, Esmond Edwards, Cal Lampley, Don Schitten and Bob Porter at Prestige; Creed Taylor in the ABC days, the Verve days and the CTI days; Herman Lubinsky (or was it always Ozzie Cadena) at Savoy; Ozzie at Choice and Prestige (Trusound) making gospel group and choir albums; Orrin Keepnews at Riverside; and others I either don't know about or have forgotten.

MG

Plus Bob Thiele with Impulse.

I knew there was one I'd missed. Forgot him.

MG

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...