Jump to content

Oscar Peterson, Short List


StarThrower

Recommended Posts

2 hours ago, jlhoots said:

Stratford Shakespearean Festival

That's a real good one.

Also consider  two other albums he made at home (in Canada, that is) :  On The Town (http://www.allmusic.com/album/on-the-town-mw0000624961) and OP Trio + One (http://www.allmusic.com/album/oscar-peterson-trio-one-mw0000615538) with Clark Terry.

I've always liked what I think was his first solo record, Tracks (http://www.allmusic.com/album/tracks-mw0000319509

Then, there's that gang of releases from the London House, and wonderful accompaniments to Lester Young, Louis Armstrong, the latter day Pablo album with Dizzy...

 

Now that I think of it, there's one hell of a lot of great music from this guy, and those who find it all a bit too much, so be it.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The '50s Basie tribute album with Buddy Rich is nice -- has a very "in there" feel. Stratford and Concertgebouw of course for that trio.

I will dissent for the most part on OP as an accompanist for the likes of Ben Webster, Coleman Hawkins, and other major figures of that vintage. His comping for them IMO tends to be quite airless and clotted -- compare, for example, his comping on Harry Edison's "Gee Baby Ain't I Good To You" with  that of Jimmy Rowles on "Sweets," with essentially the same band. An odd example is the "Getz and J.J. Johnson at the Opera House" recordings from 1957 -- half in mono from one concert (supposedly from L.A.), half in stereo from another (supposedly from Chicago -- in fact, I think the locations of the two concerts may be the other way around, not that it matters). In any case, OP and the rest of the rhythm section ( H. Ellis, R. Brown, and Connie Kay) are terrific on the mono tracks,  as are Getz and J.J., while OP is quite discombobulated/insensitive on the stereo tracks, which has a negative effect on Getz especially -- this divergence on performances separated by just a week. My guess is that on the stereo tracks the members of the group were placed too far apart on the stage for them to hear each other or the horn soloists adequately, but the difference between OP's comping on these two concerts still seems weird to me.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, l p said:

these 2.

Yes, it varied. But when OP's comping was bad IMO, it was inexplicably so along the lines I mentioned -- clottled, insensitive. Wish I could recall what musician said this, but I remember one worthwhile musician complaining as well that OP played the "wrong" changes, meaning (or so I understood this remark) that at times OP delved into his chunk-a-chunk bluesiness when the piece at hand was not a blues or even that blues-tinged.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Larry Kart said:

Yes, it varied. But when OP's comping was bad IMO, it was inexplicably so along the lines I mentioned -- clottled, insensitive. Wish I could recall what musician said this, but I remember one worthwhile musician complaining as well that OP played the "wrong" changes, meaning (or so I understood this remark) that at times OP delved into his chunk-a-chunk bluesiness when the piece at hand was not a blues or even that blues-tinged.

Miles Davis, in a blindfold test, commenting on Oscar playing "Joy Spring" [lifted from an Ethan Iverson blog item]:

 

Oscar makes me sick because he copies everybody.  He even had to learn how to play the blues.  Everybody knows that if you flat a third, you’re going to get that blues sound.  He learned that and runs it into the ground worse than Billy Taylor.  You don’t have to do that.

Now take the way he plays that song.  That’s not what Clifford meant.  He passes right over what can be done with the chords.  It’s much prettier if you get into it and heard the chords weaving in and out like Bill Evans and Red Garland could do – instead of being so heavy.  Oscar is jazzy; he jazzes up the tune.  And he sure has devices, like certain scale patterns, that he plays all the time.

Does he swing hard like some people say? I don’t know what they mean when they say ‘swing hard’ anyway.  Nearly everything he plays, he plays with the same degree of force.  He leaves no holes for the rhythm section.  The only thing I ever heard him play that I liked was his first record of “Tenderly.”

Edited by Guy Berger
Link to comment
Share on other sites

The Oscar Peterson records that I've enjoyed the most are:
- Night Train (Verve)
Oscar Peterson Trio + One [with Clark Terry] (Verve)
- My Favorite Instrument (MPS)
- Tracks (MPS)
- Oscar Peterson & Harry Edison (Pablo)

Oscar provoked (provokes?) some STRONG reactions, doesn't he?!?!  Both pro and con.  Along with Miles, Thelonious famously dismissed Peterson's playing by pointing to a toilet. And then others think he's one of the greatest pianists ever. ... I guess I fall somewhere in between.  Sometimes Peterson's playing is astonishing.  And sometimes it can be "too much of a good thing" -- at least for my tastes. ;) 

Is OP is the jazz world's equivalent to György Cziffra in classical music??? From what I've learned of Cziffra, he seemed to provoke the same sort of extreme responses, both for and against.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Another  OP goodie, but fairly obscure, is "Tenderly" (Just a Memory), with the Ellis, Brown trio from a 1958 Vancouver concert. Issued in 2002, with liner notes by Peterson discple Oliver Jones, it seems to be legit and is in excellent sound. Right up there with Stratford and the Concertgebouw.

3 hours ago, HutchFan said:

 

Is OP is the jazz world's equivalent to György Cziffra in classical music??? From what I've learned of Cziffra, he seemed to provoke the same sort of extreme responses, both for and against.

Not quite like Cziffra I think, who had a fabulous swashbuckling technique but also was known for taking notable liberties with the text.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 weeks later...

OP recorded many great ones ! Just off the the top of my head

1.Exclusively for my (MPS) 4 cd box recorded exquisitely in Germany

 2. Night Train

3. Affinity

4.Live in Tokyo /Japan (Jazz Lips - or some other Andorran grey label.A very well recorded live outing with R. Brown and E. Thigpen

5. Prez w/OP trio - outstanding !

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The funny thing is, Oscar was one of the first jazz musicians I heard, cause it seems a lot of people who usually didn´t listen to jazz, would eventually buy the one or the other OP album. OP or Garner, so maybe that´s how I got to know him, when I was a kid.

I think the two albums I heard then was the above mentioned "Night Train" and "We Get Requests". Those albums are not so "overplayed" like later stuff would be. I like some OP if he doesn´t exagerate the pianistic thing.

I like the more subdued stuff, a nice thing if the often critized "In Tune" with the Singers Unlimited, that was in fashion then , and I recently got the CD as a Chrismas present from my wife. That´s nice stuff, not so overplayed.

And lesser known, there´s a nice Pablo album Eddy Lockjaw Davis with the Oscar Peterson Trio at Montreux......

Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 hours ago, Gheorghe said:

The funny thing is, Oscar was one of the first jazz musicians I heard, cause it seems a lot of people who usually didn´t listen to jazz, would eventually buy the one or the other OP album. OP or Garner, so maybe that´s how I got to know him, when I was a kid.

 

Same impression here. I can't recall if he was one of the first I heard but he certainly was omnipresent (e.g. in jazz programs on radio in my early jazz years). This may have been one the reasons I did not search him out actively for rather a long time (and whenever I listened to or bought JATP recordings it certainly wasn't for OP either).

So in the end it was tunes that caught my ear on radio that spurred me into buying OP records that became my favorites:

- His "Exclusively for my Friends" albums recorded for MPS in the 60s, particularly the "Travelin' On" album.

- His very early 1945-49 recordings for RCA. Fine stuff with me any time. No doubt many will quibble that this is not "THE OP" as we all know him but I find them amazing anyway, no matter if to some they are more a case of OP trying to "out-teddywilson" Teddy Wilson. I bought them on the strength of tracks heard on radio and actually more as another document of 40s jazz but I am fine with that. I just take them for what they are.

 

 

Edited by Big Beat Steve
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Isn't that what a musician is all about? His playing? And if you want to know what somebody's favorites are an explanation of what they like about those favorites would not be amiss IMHO - not least of all because this should allow the OP to evaluate better why this or that recording is preferred by somebody else out these. He just "might" have different priorities and this will allow him to judge the replies accordingly. A case of "one man's meat ..." you know ... ;)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...