Jump to content

Sam Most, Schildkraut, Mettome


Larry Kart

Recommended Posts

Worth checking out is “Sam Most Plays Bird, Bud, Monk, and Miles” (Bethlehem, 1957)? Dave Schildkraut plays striking solos on tenor on five of the eight tracks -- four big band, four sextet, with charts by Bob Dorough, who also acquits himself quite well on piano. Contrary to what one might perhaps expect, the atmosphere is forthrightly boppish, not frou frou. Most is on clarinet throughout. Doug Mettome is the trumpet soloist, bold and interesting but also somewhat ragged at times — perhaps he was descending for good into junkiedom. As the other albums collected here make clear, Most was the most accomplished jazz flutist of that time, at least IMO.

71QiMee+dML._SX425_.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I also like the small-group recordings that Most made in later years for Schlitten on Xanadu. Some excellent rhythm sections on those, and Most is a very agile and interesting improviser. There are times IIRC when it seemed like he might be playing the flute in the conventional manner and whistling through it at the same time -- quite effectively so, if I'm right about that, and, again if so, not in the Roland Kirk manner. Most had a bright mind and was a swinger.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 hours ago, Larry Kart said:

I also like the small-group recordings that Most made in later years for Schlitten on Xanadu.

The only one of those I've hear was a live one that seemed to be unfortunate, at times irritatingly so, on all counts. Are the others any different?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

19 hours ago, Larry Kart said:

Worth checking out is “Sam Most Plays Bird, Bud, Monk, and Miles” (Bethlehem, 1957)? Dave Schildkraut plays striking solos on tenor on five of the eight tracks -- four big band, four sextet, with charts by Bob Dorough, who also acquits himself quite well on piano. Contrary to what one might perhaps expect, the atmosphere is forthrightly boppish, not frou frou. Most is on clarinet throughout. Doug Mettome is the trumpet soloist, bold and interesting but also somewhat ragged at times — perhaps he was descending for good into junkiedom. As the other albums collected here make clear, Most was the most accomplished jazz flutist of that time, at least IMO.

71QiMee+dML._SX425_.jpg

"Plays Bird, Bud, Monk & Miles" was one of the "ear opener" purchases among all the Fresh Sound LPs I bought back in the 90s and very early 2000s. I bought most of these unheard and without DETAILED previous knowledge of the contents (just as part of my interest in jazz from that period and curiosity about many of those somewhat under-the-radar artists) and very rarely missed, and this one was particularly striking. "I'm Nuts About the Most" which came with it isn't bad at all either - and this though I am otherwise not really into modern jazz flute and flutists. Very hard to express why maybe he sounds more like a "clarinet-flutist" and not like a "flute-flutist" to me? At any rate, I took to that "Nuts" LP while I rather shied away from Bud Shank and his WCJ flutisms, for example.

Edited by Big Beat Steve
Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 hours ago, JSngry said:

The only one of those I've hear was a live one that seemed to be unfortunate, at times irritatingly so, on all counts. Are the others any different?

All these are excellent (the rhythm sections on "Flute Flight" and "Mostly Flute" (Duke Jordan, Tal Farlow, Sam Jones, Billy Higgins -- just shoot me!) are out of sight, and the contrast between Most and Farrell on "Flute Talk"  is interesting). All in all, some serious happy music-making.

R-5521122-1395520351-6530.jpeg.jpgR-1763884-1483072918-5573.jpeg.jpg61pGhwkoBpL._AC_US218_.jpg

 

Mostly Flute - Sam Most | Songs, Reviews, Credits | AllMusic.webloc

Mostly Flute - Sam Most | Songs, Reviews, Credits | AllMusic.webloc

Mostly Flute - Sam Most | Songs, Reviews, Credits | AllMusic.webloc

Mostly Flute - Sam Most | Songs, Reviews, Credits | AllMusic.webloc

Link to comment
Share on other sites

23 hours ago, Larry Kart said:

Worth checking out is “Sam Most Plays Bird, Bud, Monk, and Miles” (Bethlehem, 1957)? Dave Schildkraut plays striking solos on tenor on five of the eight tracks -- four big band, four sextet, with charts by Bob Dorough, who also acquits himself quite well on piano. Contrary to what one might perhaps expect, the atmosphere is forthrightly boppish, not frou frou. Most is on clarinet throughout. Doug Mettome is the trumpet soloist, bold and interesting but also somewhat ragged at times — perhaps he was descending for good into junkiedom. As the other albums collected here make clear, Most was the most accomplished jazz flutist of that time, at least IMO.

71QiMee+dML._SX425_.jpg

I know Jimmy Raney played as a sideman on one Most LP. Is he on any of these four?

I saw the documentary on Most a few years back. He was a tremendous scat singer! His ideas on flute were fine, but I was surprised how small his  sound on flute was in the documentary.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, sgcim said:

I know Jimmy Raney played as a sideman on one Most LP. Is he on any of these four?

I saw the documentary on Most a few years back. He was a tremendous scat singer! His ideas on flute were fine, but I was surprised how small his  sound on flute was in the documentary.

Raney is on this one:

http://csgoshow.com/musics/619869-sam-most-the-amazing-mr-sam-most-1957-2014-bethlehem-album-collection-1000.html

Haven't listened to it yet.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 1/18/2018 at 11:23 AM, Larry Kart said:

All these are excellent (the rhythm sections on "Flute Flight" and "Mostly Flute" (Duke Jordan, Tal Farlow, Sam Jones, Billy Higgins -- just shoot me!) are out of sight, and the contrast between Most and Farrell on "Flute Talk"  is interesting). All in all, some serious happy music-making.

R-5521122-1395520351-6530.jpeg.jpgR-1763884-1483072918-5573.jpeg.jpg61pGhwkoBpL._AC_US218_.jpg

 

Mostly Flute - Sam Most | Songs, Reviews, Credits | AllMusic.webloc

Mostly Flute - Sam Most | Songs, Reviews, Credits | AllMusic.webloc

Mostly Flute - Sam Most | Songs, Reviews, Credits | AllMusic.webloc

Mostly Flute - Sam Most | Songs, Reviews, Credits | AllMusic.webloc

Ok, there are no live Xanadu albums by Sam Most, so I don't know what I'm remembering...it might have been Mostly Flute? I remember a lot of thuddy phrasing going on, and a Most/Duke Jordan combination would fit that bill...or it might have been that one with the arty cover, I honestly don't know...I just remember being pissed of at whatever it was. I do remember it on the ipod and listening while walking, any idea which one that might have been? It was pretty hot, that much I remember, I needed some incentivizing music and whatever it was, i was not feeling incentivized. Wrong record for the situation perhaps.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

"... I remember a lot of thuddy phrasing going on, and a Most/Duke Jordan combination would fit that bill."

Can't imagine why you would think that a Most/Duke Jordan combination would be less than excellent. And I can't think of a pairing between Jordan and ANYBODY that was the least bit "thuddy." Duke was one of the great accompanists.

On 1/18/2018 at 9:48 AM, JSngry said:

The only one of those I've hear was a live one that seemed to be unfortunate, at times irritatingly so, on all counts. Are the others any different?

Looking through Most's albums on Amazon, I don't see a live date.

Oops, I stand corrected:

"Sam recorded 2 albums in 2012; “A Time for Love” with Bob Alcivar and the live album “Indian Summer” with the Rein de Graaff Trio."

Never heard either one. You can find tracks from"Indian Summer" on YouTube. The bit I just heard sounded rather "thuddy."

61Kxw0qRCaL._SS500.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 hours ago, JSngry said:

Ok, there are no live Xanadu albums by Sam Most, so I don't know what I'm remembering...it might have been Mostly Flute? I remember a lot of thuddy phrasing going on, and a Most/Duke Jordan combination would fit that bill...or it might have been that one with the arty cover, I honestly don't know...I just remember being pissed of at whatever it was. I do remember it on the ipod and listening while walking, any idea which one that might have been? It was pretty hot, that much I remember, I needed some incentivizing music and whatever it was, i was not feeling incentivized. Wrong record for the situation perhaps.

Yes there are. "Xanadu at Montreux" (4 LPs from the 1978 appearance of a Xanadu all-star line-up set up by Don Schlitten at the Montreux festival).

I have Vols. 3 and 4, listened to Vol. 4 last night and found Sam Most's flute somewhat airier, more typically "flute-ish" (as opposed to the more straight-ahead phrasing - for want of a better word - on his Behtlehem "I'm Nuts About the Most" LP. But "thuddy"? And there were 20 years between the two recordings so a lot can evolve one way or another.

But this is not the one you remember. Dolo Coker and Barry Harris were on piano at Montreux.

 

Edited by Big Beat Steve
Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, Big Beat Steve said:

Yes there are. "Xanadu at Montreux" (4 LPs from the 1978 appearance of a Xanadu all-star line-up set up by Don Schlitten at the Montreux festival).

I have Vols. 3 and 4, listened to Vol. 4 last night and found Sam Most's flute somewhat airier, more typically "flute-ish" (as opposed to the more straight-ahead phrasing - for want of a better word - on his Behtlehem "I'm Nuts About the Most" LP. But "thuddy"? And there were 20 years between the two recordings so a lot can evolve one way or another.

But this is not the one you remember. Dolo Coker and Barry Harris were on piano at Montreux.

 

Actually, I think it is...the opener, "This Masquerade"...wrong band for that tune, iirc, Ted Dunbar...not needed on a George Benson cover, and neitehr was anybody elswe. My memory is of a very loose (and not in a good way) "jam" that was indeed thuddy...do you want some doobie in your funk? Or some Frank Butler? And dolo Coker, hmmm...sometimes yes, sometimes no.

As for Duke Jordan...people keep saying that he got better as he got older, but i swear, every time i hear him from the 70s on, he just sounds like he's getting older, tireder, and less imaginative. I'll replace "thuddy" with "borderline plodding" if it makes anybody feel better.

No question about his historical importance, but past that, like with later Bill Evans, I keep trying to find what "everybody else" is hearing, but i now think that whatever it is,  it's vibrating at a frequency my brain just noes not receive.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Dave Friesen playing bebop does not make me bounce. That pocket...by the time the tune was over, it was more than a heart that skipped a beat. I could hear Philly getting restles...Art Farmer sounded great, though!

The Bert cut...god bless Eddie Bert, but it's just another take on "Love Me Or Leave Me", and kind a flatlined one at that.

I like Jordan's comp, a lot, but his soloing...it just doesn't bounce to me. I can hear where he's bouncing, but it's like...it bounces more to him than it does to me, I guess. Did he have arthritis in his right hand or something? I get the "hard" attack, but...thump/plod/whatever, the feel just doesn't grab me. Maybe it's that modern recoring style, seems like he could use the air around his notes that the older recording style gave him.

Here's some Bert that bounces:

I think people in general bounced more back then, people weren't so damned obsessed with low body fat or something.

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 weeks later...

Duke Jordan was a marvelous jazz pianist. He had something unique that made his playing very identifiable to me, He recorded a lengthy list of sessions for Steeplechase and almost every one of them is, to my taste, delightful. The only things by him that I found less than terrific were  two recordings for the Japanese label M & I, and one for the Japanese label Baystate. And they were by no means bad, just a bit less interesting than his many other recordings.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...