George Coleman In Baltimore 1971 (Left Bank) out Nov 27/Dec 11

[JSngry]

9 hours ago, bertrand said:

Sickler made a stink about the Clifford Brown Aebersold book and had it pulled, from what I heard. I am not sure what the issue was. I doubt that was a best-seller.

There is ( or was?) a market for those things amongst their target market. So, yeah, there was money being made.

[bertrand]

I am not sure what the issue was. All I know was that I went to the Clifford Brown conference in Philly a few years ago and sat with Sickler and Brownie Jr. at a lunch and they were boasting about how they had had it pulled. It seemed they were suggesting Aebersold was some sort of cloak and dagger bootlegger which was absurd, he is  well-respected educator with years of experience and an NEA Jazz Master to boot. Yes, maybe someone in his office effed up some paperwork, but there was no malice intended. I find it hard to believe the issue could not have been resolved with a check and some updated agreement. Whatever.

PS: There have been some questionable Brownie composer attributions over the years. Just sayin'...

 

Edited 16 January by bertrand

[JSngry]

I went to an Aebersold clinic in 1979(?), and there was a lot of "for educational purposes only" items being sold on a cash-only basis. A lot.

Having said that, I get that it takes cash for an operation such as that to stay afloat. Still, yeah, "a check and some updated agreement" would not have been out of place, I would think. Just the cost of doing business, and make no mistake, that was/is a business.

 

[Brad]

14 hours ago, bertrand said:

Sickler made a stink about the Clifford Brown Aebersold book and had it pulled, from what I heard. I am not sure what the issue was. I doubt that was a best-seller.

Perhaps he had a lawyer send a cease and desist letter. 

[bertrand]

25 minutes ago, Brad said:

Perhaps he had a lawyer send a cease and desist letter. 

Probably, but what were the grounds?

[JSngry]

Using lead sheets without receiving permission/clearance?

[Dan Gould]

Finally listened to this, I would give it 3 or 3 1/2 stars, and the reason being that the performance of Body & Soul was a major turn-off. Saxophone gymnastics on a ballad ain't my thing, and I'll always say this: circular breathing on a ballad is a contradiction in terms.

I've never enjoyed ballads that don't stay as ballads.  I mean what story is being told? That at least one in the couple is a manic-depressive? 

Bottom line, I like, but don't love Big George, and he played as well as I'd expected. His colleagues definitely helped on the rating. Call it 4 stars, reduced by 1 star for the "ballad" feature, adding 1/2 star for pianist and trumpeter = 3 1/2 stars.

[EKE BBB]

Quite straightforward rating scheme, I would say! 😜

[bertrand]

A lot more logical than downbeat. I give it 3.5 stars also, but my rating system is more random.

There seems to be a fade-in on the first tune. Does this mean there were tape issues? Were they only able to salvage 46 minutes? Big G seems to suggest in the notes that they selected the best takes...

Or maybe they took out the intro because there was no room on the vinyl

 

 

Edited 20 January by bertrand