Jump to content

The Latest Chris-Hardbop Bout


Recommended Posts

Guest WINGY (I STAY BOMBED)

I have to go along with HARDBOP on the Chris A feud.

It was Christiern and Stapleton mainly who got DEEP blown

out of AAJ. Some people would complain if you HANGED THEM WITH A NEW ROPE!!

Here's a personal E mail I received re the DEEP episode at AAJ (at which Christiern was at the helm).

A lot of the same J.O.s post at Organnisimo as at AAJ. It's really funny....they talk all this liberal shit until you break their balls and then it's like BURN THE BOOKS...BAN HIM

Jazz prudes are the biggest enemy of JAZZ MUSIC.

And re Bessie Smith: She wasn't even a Jazz Singer. Isn't there a BLUES BOARD someplace for topics where this BLUES SINGER could be more appreciated??

WINGY

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 91
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Just to set the record straight, it was DEEP who got himself "blown off" AAJ--not anyone else. Ditto JCorner. As I said before, DEEP can be a tremendous asset, but he can also be a tremendous ass. Unfortunately, he has a history of strolling into a BBS with personal insults and offensive language strapped to his body, and when he goes POOF!, we all suffer.

The odd part of all this is that DEEP really does not believe the nonsense he posts, he is playing games--trolling, if you will.

When it comes to trolls, the best remedy is to ignore them.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest WINGY (I STAY BOMBED)

The odd part of all this is that DEEP really does not believe the nonsense he posts, he is playing games--trolling, if you will.

When it comes to trolls, the best remedy is to ignore them.

I wonder why the "IGNORE OPTION" wasn't utilized at AAJ

in regard to DEEP'S "trolling"??

And I still stand by assessment that BESSIE SMITH WAS *NOT* A JAZZ SINGER !!

Wingy

Edited by WINGY (I STAY BOMBED)
Link to comment
Share on other sites

BESSIE: Excerpts from reviews of the original edition.

  • ”Bessie” is by Chris Albertson, a Danish jazz scholar who emigrated to this country fifteen years ago. Albertson has managed a triple feat: he has written the first estimable full-length biography not only of Bessie Smith but of any black musician; he has successfully immersed himself in a black world that has almost vanished; and he has at last removed from Bessie Smith the myths that have enclosed her for almost four decades. Whitney BalliettThe New Yorker, February 24, 1973.

    The men ad women whose contributions to the lively arts have proven most durable throughout the past century have been observed, if we are fortunate enough to have been their contemporaries, in the bright light of in-person performances. First-hand evaluations by discerning critics also have helped bring our perspective into focus.
    More often, though, the great singers, musicians, dancers, actors have become dim figures, seen through a hazy mist of legend, cultism and wishful thinking. Plays, books and movies designed to eulogize them too often have simply romanticized and fictionalized.
    An imposing exception to this rule is BESSIE by Chris Albertson (Stein & Day: $7.95). The product of painstaking research, this biography of Bessie Smith is the most devastating, provocative and enlightening work of its kind ever contributed to the annals of jazz literature…. Leonard FeatherThe Los Angeles Times, January 14, 1973.
    ________________________________________________________________________

    “Bessie” is an invaluable study of an era and a personality. Most of the myths surrounding her hectic life have been passed on through writers who never took the trouble to find out the truth. Edward Albee’s play “The Death of Bessie Smith,” writings by John Hammond and other jazz authors all are obsolete now with the publication of this book. Her turbulent, tormented life will heighten appreciation for her unique vocalizing, with lyrics she wrote adding further insight to her personal drama.

    I can’t remember a book I found so gripping yet so shocking. Having been a fan of Bessie’s records for 30 years yet not knowing anything about her except the legends makes this new reference book invaluable. All the great and near-great names of jazz and swing filter through the chapters. It will make one heck of a movie if Hollywood doesn’t corrupt it in the way it fictionalized Billie Holiday’s life. Barbara BladenThe Times (San Mateo, CA), January 22, 1973.
    ________________________________________________________________________

    …a book that is not only the best biography of Bessie available, but probably the best one we’re likely to get. Arthur CooperNewsweek, January 22, 1973.
    ________________________________________________________________________

    Chris Albertson’s primary achievement in writing this book is to clear away the misinformation, obscurity surrounding Bessie Smith. This biography of the best-known blues singer ever is also a landmark in the writing of jazz history….As one of the few first-rate biographies of a jazz or blues artist, the book is a significant step in the creation of a body of jazz historiography. Hollie I. WestThe Washington Post, January 23, 1973.
    ________________________________________________________________________

    Bessie by Chris Albertson (Stein and Day, $7.95) is the life story of a woman who was advertised throughout the entertainment world as “The Greatest Blues Singer in the World.” It is by a record expert who was born and reared in Iceland and Denmark, but he tells the story so well that one would think he has been raised in the Negro show world, and believe me I have been familiar with that world for fifty years….This is a story in depth; not the press agent stuff culled from theatrical columns, but intimate details from friends, acquaintances and relatives. The story of a talented black woman who was human as well as an artist. It is not easy for a white man, and a European at that, to penetrate the black society and the life style of a black woman whom he never personally met. Chris Albertson has done it, and I urge you to read it. Schuyler New Hampshire Manchester Union Leader, January 1973.
    ________________________________________________________________________

    With the fanatical thoroughness that is the hallmark of European scholars hooked on Afro-American music, Albertson has combed the files of record companies and newspapers, and bird-dogged anyone who knew Bessie—relatives, lovers, fellow performers—to give us this first full-dress biography of an artist “black and proud before that became the acceptable thing to be.” More than a portrait of this boisterous, brooding woman, Bessie unfolds the black sub-culture of the Twenties: the speakeasies and “buffet flats” where Pullman porters and headliners reveled in a high life that rivaled the Krafft-Ebing cabarets of Berlin, the vaudeville circuits, record studios, and sheet music firms—a holocaust of rip-offs, plagiarism, non-payment, swindling contracts, and appalling racism…Bessie will take an immediate and permanent place in the literature of jazz. Grover Sales — Saturday Review of The Arts, April 1973.

    This is an honest attempt to provide at last a thoroughly researched biography of Bessie Smith. The fact that the great blues singer died so long ago (in 1937) inevitably imposed limitations on the author, but he conscientiously sought out associates who knew her well and critically re-examined the existing literature on the subject. Previous writing about her was slight and repetitious, and knowledge of her will be notably expanded by the original material to be found here. … The light the book sheds on show business of the period, its ethics and people, is valuable in itself. Stanley Dance Music Journal, April 1973.

    Although warned by advance rumours, it is still a shock for Bessie Smith admirers to discover that so much of the received mythology which we have believed as gospel is without foundation …the most radical section of the book reassesses the facts surrounding her death. Somehow her refusal by the White hospital seemed so symbolically apt that although several previous experts had done their best to discredit it, most of us wanted to believe it. Albertson has finally exploded it, checked hospital records, interviewed the heroic doctor who happened upon the disaster, refuted the whole death of Bessie Smith industry of which the playwright Edward Albee is the most recent and distinguished shareholder. George Melly The Observer Review (London), May 27, 1973.

    In the first serious study of her life, “Bessie” (Stein & Day, $7.95), author Chris Albertson paints a three-dimensional portrait of the famed blues singer, her life and times. …(Throughout the book, Albertson points out the disgraceful lack of attention paid to documenting black history.) Albertson, however, is a scholarly and meticulous researcher, careful to relate discrepancies or conflicting stories without necessarily drawing his own conclusions. His obvious attention to accuracy effectively underscores some of the tragic elements to her life, heretofore undisclosed or obscured…

    Albertson’s book bares it all; the artistic successes, the personal failures . Not only is Bessie’s person explored, but her milieu — buffet flats, Harlem night clubs, Chicago speakeasies — and the prevailing conditions, both in society at large and the recording industry in specific. Her tumultuous affairs with both men and women are depicted in detail. As are her achievements in recording. Joel Selvin San Francisco Chronicle, February 18, 1973.

    This book shows us the real Bessie Smith, victim of her times and self-appointed purveyor of the law to any who crossed her path in her struggle to survive, and no respector of persons in a class society. This is a somewhat seedy and sordid disclosure, yet presented fairly, and in no way does her biographer give the impression of being sensational for the sake of effect. There will, however, be many who feel that their favourite should have been revered with a star treatment biography, but truth will out, and Chris Albertson has produced a work worthy of the dedicated journalist, an unbiased record of the life of a legendary woman. An essential purchase this, for the jazz and blues enthusiast, or historian of the American theatre. John G. Featherstone — aired on Jazz A’Plenty, and Between the Lines, Radio Manchester (UK), May 1973.

    Chris Albertson—extraordinary, dedicated jazzman and good writer—a rare combo and so this is a rare biography… BESSIE is at once affectionate and avidly objective. It is no glossover of the bountiful, volcanic, rich and flawed lady and is obviously the result of care, time, intelligence and endless research and interviewing. Her unapologetic passion and omnisexuality are not blinked and her basic attitudes toward the society of her day are clear as when—for instance—she speaks about the flaunting, wealthy white Harlem slummery. …BESSIE is a must for all who love jazz old and-or new. It is worth a look-in even for the most mod… Ronald H. Bayes The Fayette Observer (NC), February 18, 1973.

    To set the record as straight as possible, Albertson tracked down some previously silent important sources, notably Ruby Walker, Bessie’s niece and constant companion during her last fourteen years; Jack Gee, Jr., Bessie’s adopted son, who had disappeared from sight; and jazz giant Lionel Hampton, nephew of Richard Morgan who was Bessie’s great love. Albertson has woven their recollections and already-known facts into a book that is not only the best biography of Bessie available, but probably the best one we’re likely to get. Arthur Cooper Newsweek, January 22, 1973.

__________________________

Perhaps not a "jazz" singer (some will give you an argument here), but definitely one who attracts the attention of jazz critics.

With this, my ignoring of trollery begins. :rolleyes:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest WINGY (I STAY BOMBED)

BESSIE was no more a jazz singer than Aretha Franklin, Dionne Warwick or Mahalia Jackson.

It kills me how all these European pundits try to express the "JAZZ EXPERIENCE" vicariously thru these Black artists. They sit in their Central Park apartments, London flats,

Norwegian Chateaus around their warm fireplaces and try to make money off "THE AMERICAN EXPERIENCE".

Bessie Smith was fine for State Fairs, Medicine Shows, Pentecostal Caravans,

Rodeos, Holy Roller Meetings etc.

Her recordings had a few good participants like POPs, Fletcher, Charlie Green etc. but for sure were not any kind of big influence on Jazz. At best her life could make an interesting R Rated movie but by the time the Prudes got a hold of it the rating would be GP......OH GOD...SHE USED SWEAR WORDS!!!....DUH!!

If you wanna talk about *SMITH* Jazz singers then consider KEELY SMITH...

...Yeah that's right...SHE WAS A JAZZ SINGER.

Christ, for that matter, KATE SMITH was more of a Jazz Singer than Bessie...at least she could pull off singin' a ballad. :angry:

WINGY

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The odd part of all this is that DEEP really does not believe the nonsense he posts, he is playing games--trolling, if you will.

When it comes to trolls, the best remedy is to ignore them.

I wonder why the "IGNORE OPTION" wasn't utilized at AAJ

in regard to DEEP'S "trolling"??

And I still stand by assessment that BESSIE SMITH WAS *NOT* A JAZZ SINGER !!

Wingy

There never has been a jazz singer.....

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'd like to know more about Hardbop's listening habits and Hardbop in general. He seems to be an important figure in the world of music consumption and music talk.

He'd like everyone to think that. He's nothing but a wanker, a poser, a Stanley- Crouch-wannabe. A simple glancing of any of his posts reveals his extreme pro-Wynton anti-creativity bias.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.

×
×
  • Create New...