????? So what are you saying? Perhaps I'm just not " learned" or "sophisticated" enough to understand.
Unusually, Jim hasn't been as clear as he usually is. I think he means that, in the early R&B days, the musical language was limited and therefore someone who was capable of more was letting himself down more clearly than would be the case now. So, I guess, Jim means that double standards aren't operating.
Of course, it does depend on what you're trying to get to. And if what you're trying to get to is the message of the honking R&B horns - and you happen to be Gator Tail - then doing it isn't letting yourself down. And though Gator later moved away from that stuff (a bit) and said something like "well you can lie on the floor with your foot in the bell of your sax but in the end, what are you playing for people who want to buy an album?" (can't be asked to look up the reference) I don't read that as denigrating what he was doing earlier because a) he got to be thirty and that makes a difference, b) things changed and it became an LP market and c) the public went off that kind of stuff in about 1954, so Gator had a hard time in the late fifties and it wasn't until he moved more firmly over to the jazz side that he started doing good business.
And I know not what to learn from all that
MG