I haven't heard this before. Just wondered what was the source. I know I've seen pictures of him w/scores in front of him at recording sessions (the big band stuff I presume.) Of course, he could have been using that as a chord chart.
This seems strange to me, as both of his parents were music instructors from my understanding. And taught him piano in his youth.
I could be wrong on this information. Just curious.
As for the intent of the original thread.... Opinions like his are more the rule than the exception I believe. Sophistication is acquired.
I've always been curious about that statement also, and I've heard it many times. This quote is straight from AMG: He attended the Hamilton School of Music in 1948, and Ornstein School of Music in 1949 and 1950 in Philadelphia. It always seemed to me that if someone spent three years in music school he would at least know the rudiments of sight reading.
←
Totally forgot about this old thread! Concerning Jimmy's ability to read, I believe there was an interview with him in Keyboard magazine... I think ... I know I read it somewhere, where he talked about the Verve big band sessions. I guess one of the first sessions he did... was it Oliver Nelson or Lalo Schiffrin? Anyway, they were running through the tune and the conductor said "Okay, you come in at the B section" and Jimmy said, "Ok". So they run through the tune and they get to the B section and Jimmy is just sitting there, not playing. "What's wrong?" the conductor asks. "Man, just point at me when you want me to play!" says Jimmy!
It's true, both his parents were educators. But I have a friend who took piano lessons all the way through high school who couldn't sight-read a note when he got to college. I saw him give recitals of Chopin and Bach and he couldn't sight-read a note. He learned it all by ear. And there is no doubt that Jimmy's ears were huge. I bet he could've faked his way through any music school.