I agree that is a bit condescending, but try not to be offended J.A.W. The posts at the SH forum can get a bit over the top. I do find the place to be an EXTEMELY useful resource for learning infinite, minute details about the music I love. That's really the main vibe of that place, IMO. People who love music, and don't hesitate in being passionate when discussing it, kinda like around here. And when listening to the music they love, they want to hear it in the best possible sound quality. A great place to learn about cds/lps to avoid.
My advice: take everything you read on the internet with a grain of salt. Take it in, but always use your own judgment, and yes, your own ears.
I think SH once said, "What sounds good to me, may not sound good to you..."
Sound advice, I believe...(please ignore the pun)
I have begun friendships there with several persons who I consider to be some of the best I've ever met. Same with this board.
You know, I guess I am sort of offended by calling it "Hoffman's publicity board." Not that Steve Hoffman needs me to defend him, but I think that's way off mark. Publicity for what? For good sound? How can that be a bad thing? Offering a place for people to discuss music, in a well-moderated fashion, can only be a good thing. I never seen SH as one who spends time tooting his own horn. He offers great insight on how to get good sound, and has a lot of experience with the master tapes so I really believe he's pretty qualified to make some of his judgment calls.
Geez, he even recently had another "field trip" invitation to board members to attend the mastering of "Bill Evans Trio at Shelly's Manne Hole", and some other lp I forget right now, for the Analogue Productions 45-RPM Lp. How fucking cool is that?
I'm really not out to attack you personally Robert H., but I'm not sure if you've actually spent much time on that board to warrant unkind/unfair remarks like that. Please let me know if I'm wrong here; maybe without calling me a wanker, too.
I'm not usually an internet-policeman...just another POV is all...
(gets down off soapbox)