I could absolutely understand some on not liking this movie. I guess I could also understand some on absolutely loving it, but I do not understand why it became such a cult favorite. To me, it's just a good movie, kind of stylish/stylized. but with a contrived storyline.
Recently watched
Released on DVD by Criterion under its original title, The Devil and Daniel Webster. The alternate title came from the fear in 1941 that a lot of theater owners would not be willing to put the word "Devil" on their marquees. It's a really good but also strange movie. At times it feels like a light comedy, at times like a fantasy tale and at times it takes a dark turn to the supernatural. This movie poster really would not prepare a prospective audience member for what the movie is really like.
Walter Huston and Edward Arnold are great. Edward Arnold's performance as Daniel Webster is even more impressive given that he had to come in as a replacement after much of the film had already been shot when the original actor had a serious on-set accident. James Craig is good as the down to earth, New Hampshire farmer whose life is changed dramatically by his deal with the devil.
This was only the second film scored by Bernard Herrmann (following something called Citizen Kane) and for it he won his first and only (!!!) Oscar. Another Kane alumnus, Robert Wise, did some wonderful editing work here.
(An interesting bit of trivia: Gene Lockhart was the father of June Lockhart and he also wrote the lyrics to "The World Is Waiting For The Sunrise".)