Some stressful things are happening at work. To keep myself distracted, today I decided to conduct an impromptu listening experiment. I just finished listening to to ten different recordings of Beethoven's Piano Sonata No. 31 in A flat major, Op. 110. The recordings I chose:
Arrau (Philips)
Barenboim (DG)
Brendel (Philips I)
Buchbinder (Teldec)
Hungerford
Kempff (DG II)
Kovacevich (Warner Classics)
Pollini
Serkin (1960)
Solomon
I enjoyed listening to all of these recordings, but -- for this listener, today -- three stood out. They are (in no particular order):
KOVACEVICH - for his dark and brooding weightiness; it's a "heavy" reading--in the best sense of the word. Think Otto Klemperer.
SERKIN - for his sense of pathos and subsequent joyousness; there's also a singing quality in Serkin's playing that brings the "Choral" Symphony to mind.
HUNGERFORD - for creating such a profound sense of drama; if you want a visual image of Hungerford's way with this music, think of Zeus, his arm raised above his head, casting his lightning bolt.
It's fun to do these sorts of listening comparisons, occasionally. It's a bit like comparing ten different jazz versions of "Body and Soul." Some might be more important than others (historically speaking), but I'm resistant to the idea of finding a "definitive" one.
So, do you have a favorite recording of LvB's Op.110 sonata?