You can indeed. And if your choice is between there and paying for Pujols xeroxes, you're a chump if you pay. If not a chump, then at least a "good lad". (EDIT to add "in my opinion". Must remain civil at all times!)
If you have some innate...inbred compulsion to "follow the rules" at all times, then...your choice. Follow your bliss, wherever you've been told it should lead.
(Whatever happened to that Empire, anyway? Oh yeah, people got tired of following rules that didn't make sense for them, especially when it came to their resources. Good to see a few diehard loyalists, though!)
ASCAP "explains the law" in such a way that the kid who gets his Lady Gaga for free will now pay 99 cents for it. Period. Again, are you serious? God, I hope not...
File under "Knows the cost of everything and the value of nothing".
Uh, yeah. Only, one guy is more than happy to take your money for bullshit and one guy is telling you to save it for something better. Exactly Identical, yeah.
You'll never get "the real story" . And you'd never get it even if you did.
But I will tell you this - I do not do "file-sharing". Your use of the term - which is descriptive of a very precise technology - suggests that you think you know more than you do.
But that much has already been made obvious.