That's a good observation. I mean, you can fly around on the instrument, guys like Rosolino, Watrous, & Ray Anderson have proved that, and I dig Anderson big lots, Rosolino quite a bit, & Watrous I respect. But yeah, you gotta work harder on the bone to do what's already hard. There's definitely other ways to approach the instrument, ways that are more "intrinsic" to the nature of the instrument, and overall, it's the cats who hit it that way that I tend to gravitate towards. Just like I tend to prefer bass player who play a bass like a bass rather than a like a guitar. It's all good, ya'know, but I do have my personal preferences. Sue me.
The thing I've always dug about Grachan's playing and writing is the high degree of specificity, the total lack of superfulousness. And that's not equating "high-density" with "lack of specificity" either. It just means that when your playing and writing is as totally devoid of "filler" as Moncur's has been over the years, you damn well better be able to say exactly what you want to say. With a few exceptions (notably some things from a few years ago where it sounded like his chops were pretty much gone), that's what he's done, and the clarity of communication of vision that's resulted has been something that I very much appreciate. No ambiguity of intent, no foo-foo, no licks to kill time waiting for a real idea to pop up. In short, no "diversion" from the core expression. "Shortest distance between two points" and all that.