I had always like Lloyd well enough, but he was definitely not a priority for me. But then I ran into a crowd for whom Lloyd was magic. Serious players, not "hippie" fans. The biggest hook for them was his tone, and the only Atlantics that were kind of sloughed of were the two Fillmore records. And sometimes his flute playing is just a little too...intentionally "precious" for my taste. I've never heard anybody passionately advocate for his flute work, even today.
So I went back, re-listened, and yeah, ok, I got it, the deal with the tone.. And those ECM records showed a real development and deepening of what was already a very distinctive sound across the entire range f the instrument. So...I get the earlier dissing, but don't agree with it. And the ECMs were really, REALLY good. No matter what had (or hadn't been) going on up until that point, those records showed a full blossoming, imo.
The pre-Atlantic records on Columbia (and the live performances that were released a while back) hold up really well, imo. Definitely.
On Atlantic, only Dream Weaver stands alone imo, no context needed. Forest Flower wasthe big hit, but...it's not necessarily a great record, especially as an LP, where you got one side that's now "legendary" and anther one that...does anybody ever play THAT side?