Late to the dance. Most of the music was unfamiliar to me - hope there's not something there that I have in my collection & didn't recognize.
1 - Didn't grab me. Seemed as if the musicians were on cruise control.
2 - Seemed like an exercise rather than music.
3 - I used to have a couple of Colin Nancarrow LPs in my collection. This sounded like something I remember from those.
4 - No idea who, but I love this one & want to get it when I find out who it is.
5 - Blues pianist - Might be something I may have in my collection, but I can't place it. Liked this track.
6 - Great trombone, tho no idea who. Another I'd buy.
7 - No comment - except not to my taste.
8 - Monk's "Bye-Ya". Liked the fact that the pianist tried to step outside and not play Monk's music as a Monk clone or turning it into a straight improviation. It wasn't completely successful to my ears, but props for trying something different.
9 - "Old Man River" - Didn't grab me. Strangely recorded - was it a drummer led session?
A musician friend has a line that it's more fun to play in a big band than to listen to one.
I'm not a musician, but I can imagine that being true - with a number of notable exceptions.
10 - Not sure if I ever need to hear another vocal version of "Willow Weep for Me". Enjoyed the pianist's contributions very much. Thought of Ran Blake, but probably not he.
11 - I'd buy this one just for the violinist's playing. The band's energy sounded a bit forced/unrelaxed to me, but perhaps that's what people needed back in the 30's - assume that's when it was recorded.
12 - First time I listened, I thought someone trying to do a Dolphy. Second time I listened, I thought perhaps it is Dolphy. Third time, I decided for sure that it wasn't Dolphy. No idea who it is. Arrangement sounded like they copped some things from Mingus, but without Mingus' magic. Each time I listened, I went back & forth between liking it and feeling that at times someone was being different just to be different.
13 - Kept waiting for something to happen. Then waiting for it to end. That said, I'm curious to know who this is.
14 - Liked this one some, but I have the feeling that this wasn't the saxophonist's strongest playing. Don't know who it is, but I just had the feeling that there was something more to be heard.
Seems as if I had a lot of negative comments, but I did find a number of tracks that I enjoyed enough to add to my collection. And, if that was a Nancarrow piano roll, I'm kind of sorry I traded my Nancarrow LPs.