Jump to content

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 9.2k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted Images

Posted

I like the earliest of Van Vogt and find it extremely interesting reading them now as a not younger person how influential his work was on a whole generation or two of writers. And how deeply paranoid or just plain hard and gnarly a lot of it is.

Posted

Now reading

n2848.jpg

Same cover as the one I read (back in 8th grade) but I don't think mine said "Ninth big printing" on it.

Poor old van Vogt couldn't write a novel to save his life. Notice how Slan breaks down into 15-25 page segments, like short stories but without any endings, all stitched together in only the loosest way. There's almost no narrative thread at all. Perhaps that's why so many of his novelistic heroes are men who've lost their memory for some reason.

Posted

I like the earliest of Van Vogt and find it extremely interesting reading them now as a not younger person how influential his work was on a whole generation or two of writers. And how deeply paranoid or just plain hard and gnarly a lot of it is.

Maybe I should dig out that copy of The World of Null-A I've got and give it a try again. At least I won't have high expectations to contend with this time around...

Posted

Now reading

n2848.jpg

Same cover as the one I read (back in 8th grade) but I don't think mine said "Ninth big printing" on it.

Poor old van Vogt couldn't write a novel to save his life. Notice how Slan breaks down into 15-25 page segments, like short stories but without any endings, all stitched together in only the loosest way. There's almost no narrative thread at all. Perhaps that's why so many of his novelistic heroes are men who've lost their memory for some reason.

I'm reading an edition not unlike that you read; mine is the 7th printing,without the "banner" on the cover.

I don't quite agree with your assessment of his novel-writing skills. He is using bi-focal viewpoint here, with the two Slan characters as the narrative point, and their different stories alternating. I don't find it disconcerting or particularly clumsy after the first few transitions.

Posted

"Midnight's Children" - Salman Rushdie

I'm about a quarter of the way through it and still not too sure what I think about it. Has anyone else read any Rushdie novels?

Posted (edited)

Now reading

n2848.jpg

Same cover as the one I read (back in 8th grade) but I don't think mine said "Ninth big printing" on it.

Poor old van Vogt couldn't write a novel to save his life. Notice how Slan breaks down into 15-25 page segments, like short stories but without any endings, all stitched together in only the loosest way. There's almost no narrative thread at all. Perhaps that's why so many of his novelistic heroes are men who've lost their memory for some reason.

I'm reading an edition not unlike that you read; mine is the 7th printing,without the "banner" on the cover.

I don't quite agree with your assessment of his novel-writing skills. He is using bi-focal viewpoint here, with the two Slan characters as the narrative point, and their different stories alternating. I don't find it disconcerting or particularly clumsy after the first few transitions.

But as I recall, ALL of his books are exceedingly episodic. At least the ones I read; Slan, both the Null-A books (for my sins), The War With the Rull and a couple others whose names now escape me. Of course, I'm going by memories three decades old and more, but Damon Knight backs me up on this.

Edited by BruceH
Posted

Well to each their very own. I don't remember gushing to myself about his skills, nor do I remember cursing or crumbling up books in frustration. :) Anyway, I don't think I have problems with his novels. Maybe it's just me.

Posted

I certainly didn't curse, or crumple his books (crumple a book? Heaven forfend!) They had enough interesting moments, striking images, or cool ideas that I obviously kept going with them. (Though the last couple whose names escape me---Quest For the Future? Supermind?---I never finished.) It's just that after a while I concluded that he wasn't one of my favorite science fiction authors. Your mileage, as they say, may indeed vary quite a bit.

Posted

I don't consider him one of my favorite science fiction writers either. (And I was just joshing about the cursing and crumpling!) And he's not the smoothest writer . . . I appreciate his ideas and concepts more than the writing. But. . . I don't feel that "he couldn't write a novel to save his life."

My mileage does vary. That's okay.

PS: There are three Null-A books. :)

Posted

Now reading

n2848.jpg

One of my favourites. Earlier van Vogt is inventive and nutty, kind of like of Chewy post. The later books are unintelligible and lose the fun.

Meanwhile, I'm reading Emma by Jane Austen, which is fabulous.

Posted

Now reading

n2848.jpg

One of my favourites. Earlier van Vogt is inventive and nutty, kind of like of Chewy post. The later books are unintelligible and lose the fun.

Meanwhile, I'm reading Emma by Jane Austen, which is fabulous.

Glad Jane Austen doesn't post here, all the same. I'll settle for Chewy :)

Posted

"Sing Me Back Home" Ny Times reporter Dana Jennings mixes analysis of his favorite country songs and artists with a recounting of his hillbilly upbringing in, believe it or not, rural New Hampshire.

Posted

Just started Balzac's "La Comédie Humaine," starting with "Le Père Goriot." I've never read Balzac.

Heavy stuff! Those who had to study it at my school in the 1950s used to call him "balls ache" :(

Posted

Rick Perlstein's "Nixonland." Very pertinent to our current electoral dustup. Rick is a very knowledgable jazz fan BTW, as well (so he volunteered a few years back)as an admirer of the work of yours truly, so how bad can he be?

Posted

Rick Perlstein's "Nixonland." Very pertinent to our current electoral dustup. Rick is a very knowledgable jazz fan BTW, as well (so he volunteered a few years back)as an admirer of the work of yours truly, so how bad can he be?

Still reading NIXONLAND myself--right now in the midst of the 1972 election.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.

×
×
  • Create New...