I agree with you about Giddins, but that's certainly not true of Francis, who is very aware of recent happenings and covers virtually everything - as for Murray, my experience performing with him was well after he had fully developed his style, and I stand by what I said earlier, that I believe he has developed a certain approach and coasted on it. He's certainly a good muscian but there are many tenor players who can do what he does and can do it better -as for Larry's article, yes, it was 1985, but Murray's style certainly has not changed since than and Larry's criticisms hold up -