I've always had a hard time listening to Pepper in "present tense", even when he was alive, maybe because the operative word there seemed to be "tense". That's why I tend to prefer the later stuff, the "tenseness" is owned up to and actually embraced. And for a guy like Pepper, who always seemed to be gaming in one way or another, and for whom the game seemed to be hiding just how fucked up he was (in a not necessarily cosmically "bad" way, mind you), well, that just seems to be a logical progression towards "redemption", although if anybody could said to have been irresolutely "damned" (again, in a not necessarily cosmically "bad" way, mind you), I'd say it would have to be Pepper.
That's just how it's felt to me. I make no claims of "rightness" in matters such as this.