Eddie Matthews was known as a good but not great defender
And to see Beltre rated above Brooks, ok, but he was certainly an elite defender. I watched that first hand. But at best, as good as Brooks.
Otherwise, for those other guys, yeah yeah yeah, but Brooks was pretty handy or better with a bat, so would I replace any of them with him, or vice versa? I think not.
Again, you can put a bat anywhere. But if you got Brooks Robinson, he's your 3rd Baseman.
The Os infield of Brooks, Belanger, Davey Johnson, and Boog Powell (on the receiving end) was a true delight!