Jim - You make a good defense of Michael Cuscuna the producer/reissuer. I too appreciate what he's done with Mosaic, Arista Freedom, Impulse, etc.
But - let's just look at the words he wrote:
QUOTE
...Sam and Bea opened a performance space within their loft which they called Studio Rivbea. The emotional excesses of the sixties had subsided. The influx of creative technically proficient musicians from Chicago, St. Louis and Detroit shoved a lot of the screaming pretenders off the scene. Freedom was no longer equated with anger and lack of musicianship. Studio Rivbea became an incubator for a lot of serious, new developments in experimental jazz and the forerunner of an alternate way of presenting music in New York.
The man used a number of inflammatory and mean spirited phases and sentences to make implications about a group of musicians without naming any names. Where I come from, that's called using smear tactics.
I might add that you don't have to slam one group of musicians in order to pimp another group of musicians. Jim, I don't recall you ever having done that in your posts - generally if you don't have something positive to say about a musician, you don't say anything - and I don't see why you give Michael Cuscuna a free pass to do it.
Probably this whole thing is going "waaay overboard", as you put it. You see what he wrote as sloppy writing, and I see it another way. I do hope that we can agree to disagree. In the end, only Michael Cuscuna knows what he intended.
I'll end my part of this here. I do appreciate what Michael Cuscuna has done for the music over the years, and I've perhaps overreacted to one paragraph that he wrote. I have a tendency to do that when I feel that a person or a group of people have been treated unfairly - part of my nature.