Well Moose,
Here's my suggestion, listen to John McLaughlin's electric guitar from his Miles period and then listen to "After the Rain" under his own name or other cds he has made in the last decade, compare the tone of the guitar, which sounds more like a real guitar to you or which tone do you prefer?
compare the tone on John Scofield's cd "Time on My Hands" or some other cd from that period to your Wes Montgomery cds, I think you will hear a big difference, as to what you like better, I guess it will just be personal preference.
I am saying that since electric guitarists can add so many tone altering devices it can seriously change the sound of the instrument.