Maybe so, and to each his own opinion and likes and dislikes, but does this force anybody else beyond that "inner circle" that you seem to be alluding to to automatically agree with this (or to put it another way, does this mean that it is wrong to ask questions about whether or why this dislike is well-founded?)
No, of course not. Well, excluding Wynton Marsalis, of course...
But I think Clementine's approach went a bit beyond the level of asking questions or disagreeing.