I guess I was just pointing out the difference between hipster and hip - Jack's point is well taken, but personally I often find it illuminating to hear why some people don't like certain musicians who are generally regarded as beyond criticism - I was thinking of Larry Kart's interesting comments, for example, on Bill Evans (and of Max Harrison, who has criticized late Coltrane - but let's not get started on THAT!) - sometimes, at least to me, it provides a useful perspective. Not to open a new can of worms, but I have had interesting discussions with some jazz people on the topic of well-respected jazz players that they don't like - and, as I said, it often speaks to some useful points- I was hesitant here, at first, because I hate to seem perpetually oppositional, but Dexter is, also interestingly, one of the names that seems to come up in those conversations (and a few of these people are fellow jazz musicians) -