He played long solos on the gig I attended, but repeated himseld after a while, using the same showy tricks all the time. The groove was there, but as it was a concert type situation with the audience calmly sitting down, they should have opted for a higher level of musical content.
I saw them on TV two weeks later in a broadcast from one of Germany's most populat and long-standing jazz festivals - basically, same thing.
Carter and Gibbs have more in the can than this. I expect fun and showmanship and groove, which I got, but from a guy with such an abundance of talent at his disposal like James Carter, I expect a little more.
Maybe he feels pissed off by the labels - Warner acted strange, left the duo with Chestnut (which is good!) in the can, and the Lady Day tribute on Columbia seemed to be a one shot deal.
Yes, he seems to be meandering around searching for a direction - maybe the road experience will help.