I was thinking about that after posting. Looking back, to what really attracted me to the music, I probably should have gone nuts buying McCoy Tyner CDs, not John Coltrane. You have to remember, I was coming to this from rock, not other jazz. The main attraction was just that there didn't seem to be any wasted notes. I can't really say it was minimalist, but there was a certain almost crystalline feel to the music that attracted me. As for why it clicked with me and not for you, it's probably that. I couldn't compare it to other Coltrane LPs, or even other jazz LPs so it became my 'jazz baseline'.