I have a question for anyone here who writes instrumental melody-based compositions:
To what degree do you consider the "singability" of the melody - even if it is an instrumental - in terms of phrase lengths, places to breathe, interval jumps, range of he melody, etc.?
I write a variety of instrumental things, but whenever I write something that is primarily melody-based, I find myself thinking of the ability to sing it, for better or worse. I don't know if this is positive, in that it forces me to be economical or to think on a level that taps into something more primal, or if it is a needless limitation that I impose on myself.
Just curious to know if anyone has thoughts on this topic.