Jewish jazz musicians

[BillF]

Does it mention which hotel?

Yes. The Premier.

[AllenLowe]

hmmm....Dave Schildkraut told me that they had a place called Eager's Garden, up in the Catskills.

Many years ago, when I was seeking out old beboppers (like Curely Russell, Tommy Potter, Haig, Gene Quill and others) I was desperately trying to find Eager, as I thought he must be the most interesting guy around, loved his playing and thought he must have an interesting story. I had no luck for years and, finally, he was appearing at the Newport/NYC jazz fest (well, maybe it was the Cool Fest that year - coulda been around 1980 or so). So I found out what hotel he was staying at, called and talked to him, and boy, was he a jerk, nasty and vain. And unfortunately his playing (as I recall he appeared onstage with Al Cohn and maybe someone else) was just terrible.

Edited July 14, 2010 by AllenLowe

[AllenLowe]

just found reference to this at an internet sight that covers the old Catskill circuit:

"Eager Rose Garden"

sounds like the place Schildkraut was talking about.

more internet stuff:

"Allen Eager, tenor sax, b. New York, NY, USA. d. April 13, 2003, Daytona Beach, FL, USA (liver cancer). Eager's parents owned and operated the "Eager Rose Garden" hotel for many years in what was then the town of Bushville (now called 'Harris' - near the town of Callicoon, New York), on which property now stands the 'Catskill Regional Medical Center'"

[mjzee]

Still doesn't answer whether Eager was Jewish. There were also Italian hotel enclaves in the Catskills, and I think also Irish. Will have to dig further.

[JSngry]

This guy looks like Elvis. Was Elvis Jewish?

[mjzee]

OK, here's a clue:

Yale Strom's The Book of Klezmer has some wonderful anecdotes from former Dave Tarras trumpet player Sheldon “Shelly” Hendler about how Tarras was viewed by jazz musicians.[3] Hendler played with Dave Tarras from 1952 to 1959, starting when he was a senior in high school.[4] Accordion to Hendler, Tarras was a wonderful player of Yiddish music, but he didn't fully understand American music. He says that Tarras never had a sense of the ABA form, and would start another tune when he was supposed to come in with the next section. But his playing of the Yiddish music excelled, especially the improvisational doyne, which could last up to an hour. Saxophonist Allen Eager’s mother owned a hotel where Tarras and his band were playing, and Eager would bring up jazz musicians friends including Charlie Parker, Miles Davis, and Red Rodney to hear Taras play. These jazz musicians were only interested in the modal (Yiddish, and primarily the doynes) music that Dave played.

Source: http://matttemkin.info/Masters_Thesis/Chapter_4.html

[bodine]

Hal Stein - sax

Harvey Leonard - piano

Steve Elson - sax

Harvey Wainapel - sax

Jennie Stein (Graciela Carriqui) - singer

Mel Martin - sax

Mark Levine - piano

Mark Soskin - piano

Al Plank - piano

Bob Newman - sax

Kitty Margolis - singer

Rob Schneiderman - sax

Rob Schneider - sax

Dave Berkman - piano

Louis Kahn - trombone

Peter Apfelbaum - sax

Jessica Fuchs (Jess Jones) - sax

Lee Bloom - piano

Myron Cohen - drums

Michael Brecker - sax

Randy Brecker - trumpet

Dave Berger - piano

Bobby Rosenstein - drums

Art Lande - piano

New guy here. Was gonna mention Steve Lacy and the Brecker Brothers, but see they're already mentioned. One small bit of Jewish geography--both they and jazz fusion guy Jeff Lorber went to same high school in suburban Philly...

Edited July 15, 2010 by Trey

[Shrdlu]

I think that what others meant in their comments about Jewish people is that they have a number of people that are gifted (in all sorts of areas) that is way out of proportion to their total numbers. Musicians, scientists, and so on.

This is not at all derogatory. It's good stuff.

The reason is that the Jews are God's chosen people. Their achievements are a sign of God's blessing.

[clifford_thornton]

Clement Greenberg, the art critic and writer, has an interesting essay on Jewishness and self-criticism, which he believes enters into the ideal of high achievement in arts, sciences and letters for Jewish men.

[mjzee]

Nah, it's all that good food: knishes, pastrami, corned beef, brisket, kishka, kasha varnishkes, chicken soup... Jewish soul food!

[JSngry]

Clement Greenberg, the art critic and writer, has an interesting essay on Jewishness and self-criticism, which he believes enters into the ideal of high achievement in arts, sciences and letters for Jewish men.

Truth be told, self-criticism (aka humility about one's self at some level) is essential for any sustained high achievement in any field.

It's also a quality that has sorely and consistently been pushed out out the general consciousness for the last...half-century, if not more?

[mjzee]

But none of this explains Adam Sandler.

[AllenLowe]

and let us not forget Alan Sherman - and The Tobias Brothers.

[P.L.M]

Two pianists from New York (who are also friend of mine).

- Borah Bergman

- Noah Rosen

You're consider jewish by the jewish community if you're born of a jewish mother.

[Mike Gerber]

Does that mean Jeff Lorber's Jewish too?

Hal Stein - sax

Harvey Leonard - piano

Steve Elson - sax

Harvey Wainapel - sax

Jennie Stein (Graciela Carriqui) - singer

Mel Martin - sax

Mark Levine - piano

Mark Soskin - piano

Al Plank - piano

Bob Newman - sax

Kitty Margolis - singer

Rob Schneiderman - sax

Rob Schneider - sax

Dave Berkman - piano

Louis Kahn - trombone

Peter Apfelbaum - sax

Jessica Fuchs (Jess Jones) - sax

Lee Bloom - piano

Myron Cohen - drums

Michael Brecker - sax

Randy Brecker - trumpet

Dave Berger - piano

Bobby Rosenstein - drums

Art Lande - piano

New guy here. Was gonna mention Steve Lacy and the Brecker Brothers, but see they're already mentioned. One small bit of Jewish geography--both they and jazz fusion guy Jeff Lorber went to same high school in suburban Philly...

[Mike Gerber]

I hope Allen Eager was Jewish, as I've mentioned him as such in my book.

OK, here's a clue:

Yale Strom's The Book of Klezmer has some wonderful anecdotes from former Dave Tarras trumpet player Sheldon “Shelly” Hendler about how Tarras was viewed by jazz musicians.[3] Hendler played with Dave Tarras from 1952 to 1959, starting when he was a senior in high school.[4] Accordion to Hendler, Tarras was a wonderful player of Yiddish music, but he didn't fully understand American music. He says that Tarras never had a sense of the ABA form, and would start another tune when he was supposed to come in with the next section. But his playing of the Yiddish music excelled, especially the improvisational doyne, which could last up to an hour. Saxophonist Allen Eager’s mother owned a hotel where Tarras and his band were playing, and Eager would bring up jazz musicians friends including Charlie Parker, Miles Davis, and Red Rodney to hear Taras play. These jazz musicians were only interested in the modal (Yiddish, and primarily the doynes) music that Dave played.

Source: http://matttemkin.info/Masters_Thesis/Chapter_4.html

[Mike Gerber]

Ah yes, confirmation. I've just flicked through Susan J Miller's memoir, Never Let Me Down. She writes: "The musicians who came to our house fascinated me ... Allen Eager, Tiny Kahn, George Handy, Stan Getz, Johnny Mandel, Georgie Auld - these names resonate in my heart like the Yiddish that I heard so often then"

I hope Allen Eager was Jewish, as I've mentioned him as such in my book.

OK, here's a clue:

Yale Strom's The Book of Klezmer has some wonderful anecdotes from former Dave Tarras trumpet player Sheldon “Shelly” Hendler about how Tarras was viewed by jazz musicians.[3] Hendler played with Dave Tarras from 1952 to 1959, starting when he was a senior in high school.[4] Accordion to Hendler, Tarras was a wonderful player of Yiddish music, but he didn't fully understand American music. He says that Tarras never had a sense of the ABA form, and would start another tune when he was supposed to come in with the next section. But his playing of the Yiddish music excelled, especially the improvisational doyne, which could last up to an hour. Saxophonist Allen Eager’s mother owned a hotel where Tarras and his band were playing, and Eager would bring up jazz musicians friends including Charlie Parker, Miles Davis, and Red Rodney to hear Taras play. These jazz musicians were only interested in the modal (Yiddish, and primarily the doynes) music that Dave played.

Source: http://matttemkin.info/Masters_Thesis/Chapter_4.html

[tranemonk]

Anat Cohen and her brothers.

[mjzee]

This seems a good place to note this Nat Hentoff article I read recently in the Journal. While not specifically about jazz, it is mentioned...

Cantors, Klezmorim and Crooners 1905-1953

[AllenLowe]

Tommy Flanagan?

no, sorry, he was Irish.

[clifford_thornton]

Guitarist Amanda Monaco.

[randissimo]

3 more..

Ben Sidran

Jeff Haas

Kenny Werner

Edited August 9, 2010 by randissimo

[BillF]

I hope it's OK to include two Jewish non-professional musicians, Alan Rose and Paul Woodrow.

Alan Rose, who is from Leeds, England, won a young British jazz pianist contest in the 1960s. The prize was a week in New York City, with visits to jazz clubs and an appearance on television, sitting in for one number with Al Cohn/Zoot Sims. Recalling it recently, he told me Jimmy Garrison was on bass and Gus Johnson on drums and the number was a twelve-bar blues (of course!)

Paul Woodrow, originally also from Leeds, but now long resident in Calgary, Alberta, plays both modern jazz piano and blues keyboards. He names Victor Feldman, Carl Perkins and Wynton Kelly as his favorite pianists. He currently plays keyboards with the Rooster Blues Band, based in Calgary. Here they are backing blues singer Lou Pride in Boston:

http://www.bu.edu/today/node/5296

[david weiss]

p.s. also trumpeter David Weiss.

Are you sure about that?

I'm pretty sure.....

[davidsherr]

Yo! What am I, chopped liver?

Hey, if Michael Weiss isn't chopped liver then neither am I.