BFT 262 - Discussion Thread

[Dan Gould]

Let's get this party started, if anyone is so inclined New Year's Eve.

10 tunes / 66 minutes or so.

Same programming approach as a year ago, in this case five pairs of different performances of the same tune.  All but one are standards and I expect will at least be ID'd.  One track is an absolute gimme but that means its probably 50/50 ID'd/missed.  No Percy France, no Gene Harris.  Actually there isn't even a faux Gene Harris track to throw you off.

 

https://thomkeith.net/2026-organissimo-blindfold-tests/

 

[felser]

1 – Highly enjoyable, especially enjoying the bass player and piano.    ****

2 – Funkier than I’m used to from Dan!  Electric sax(es) wear, as does wah-wah guitar Composition and arrangement don’t anything for me.  Dave Sanborn? *

3 – Things ain’t what they used to be, indeed!   Back on the enjoyable good foot.  ***1/2

4 – All the things you are.  I like the bass player, but the whole thing is pretty ragged, though still enjoyable ***1/2

5 – Who Can I Turn To.  Nicely done all around, love the pianist’s work!  Enjoyed the guitar. ****

6 – Things… again.  Good blues playing, but I enjoyed the approach on the first version more. ***

7 – Killer!  This is the one cut I need if I don’t already own it!  I should be able to ID the song, but am going blank on the title.  I bet the whole album is good.  ****1/2

8 – Who Can I Turn To, in a comatose version.   Not doing well with this cut and especially this tenor player, though it’s probably someone you love.  Sorry.  **

9 – All The Things You Are, slowed down and on clarinet.  I like this tune fast, though I don’t hate on this the way I did the previous cut.  But I also don’t need to hear it again.  **1/2

10 – See comments to #2, although at least the sax isn’t electrified, and the conga solo is kind of cool.  *1/2

No artist ID’s, a range of responses, and I look forward to the reveals on my favorite cuts (1,5,7 especially, but also 3,4), and I expect I have one or two of them on the shelves already.

Have a safe and prosperous 2026, my friend!

[Dan Gould]

11 hours ago, felser said:

1 – Highly enjoyable, especially enjoying the bass player and piano.    ****

2 – Funkier than I’m used to from Dan!  Electric sax(es) wear, as does wah-wah guitar Composition and arrangement don’t anything for me.  Dave Sanborn? *

YES - Sanborn.  Chosen purely to allow me to include track 10.  I wonder if anyone can ID it and from there, knock off #10 too. BTW my info doesn't mention electrified sax.

3 – Things ain’t what they used to be, indeed!   Back on the enjoyable good foot.  ***1/2

4 – All the things you are.  I like the bass player, but the whole thing is pretty ragged, though still enjoyable ***1/2

5 – Who Can I Turn To.  Nicely done all around, love the pianist’s work!  Enjoyed the guitar. ****

Have never heard the song as anything but a ballad so this one really stood out.

6 – Things… again.  Good blues playing, but I enjoyed the approach on the first version more. ***

Again ... alternate approaches.  I nearly chose The Three Sounds version from the Moods LP which is even slower and a major favorite from the first time I heard it.

7 – Killer!  This is the one cut I need if I don’t already own it!  I should be able to ID the song, but am going blank on the title.  I bet the whole album is good.  ****1/2

You loved the track but had no guesses on the one chosen as a Gimme.  I wonder how long it will take before you smack yourself on the head when somebody does get it.

8 – Who Can I Turn To, in a comatose version.   Not doing well with this cut and especially this tenor player, though it’s probably someone you love.  Sorry.  **

Well I already had a gimme and I wasn't going to use Dex's version from Clubhouse!

9 – All The Things You Are, slowed down and on clarinet.  I like this tune fast, though I don’t hate on this the way I did the previous cut.  But I also don’t need to hear it again.  **1/2

To me this may be even more extreme in the opposite direction than the bouncy Who Can I Turn To. The clarinetist mentions in the liners wanting to bring this tune back to what it was written as, a lovely ballad.  I think he does that in spades, and it was a big revelation to me. Mileage.

10 – See comments to #2, although at least the sax isn’t electrified, and the conga solo is kind of cool.  *1/2

Hoping @mikeweil listens and has thoughts on the congas.

No artist ID’s, a range of responses, and I look forward to the reveals on my favorite cuts (1,5,7 especially, but also 3,4), and I expect I have one or two of them on the shelves already.

Have a safe and prosperous 2026, my friend!

You also and thanks as always for your unvarnished thoughts!

 

Edited 3 hours ago by Dan Gould

[randyhersom]

No misses!
1. Sounds like two different tracks were merged into track 1.  The first had me thinking Lockjaw.
2. and 2 repeats the second part of 1.  Parts of it almost exactly duplicate Pickin Up the Pieces by Average White Band.  Wonder which came first.  No worries either way, an enjoyable piece of R&B played by capable jazz players.
3. a Duke cover.  Is it Things Ain't What They Used to Be?  Illinois Jacquet?  Live, so maybe JATP?
4. All the Things You Are.  Something about the opening made me think of Ira Sullivan.
5. Guitar and tenor featured prominently.
6. Nice greasy bassline.  Is it Things Ain't What They Used to Be?
7. Fast bebop.  Jaws and Griff?
8. Is this Who Can I Turn to?  Nice gruff tenor, but maybe not as gruff as Ben Webster, so maybe a good time to guess Percy France.
9.  All the Things You are slowed down to ballad pace on a clarinet.  Buddy DeFranco?
10. Average White Band?  Nah, too long for a radio band.  An enjoyable piece of R&B played by capable jazz players.

[Dan Gould]

26 minutes ago, randyhersom said:

No misses!

Music to my ears!!

1. Sounds like two different tracks were merged into track 1.  The first had me thinking Lockjaw.

@tkeith!  I made a mistake on the upload of Track 1 to Thom's server, which I caught yesterday and Thom had fixed.  When I double checked his correction, the fix hadn't seemed to take but when I tried on a different PC all was fine. So I have no clue how you heard my original error.

2. and 2 repeats the second part of 1.  Parts of it almost exactly duplicate Pickin Up the Pieces by Average White Band.  Wonder which came first.  No worries either way, an enjoyable piece of R&B played by capable jazz players.

Never heard this tune or, to my knowledge Average White Band unless they had a hit that I would unwittingly know.  Felser got the leader above.

3. a Duke cover.  Is it Things Ain't What They Used to Be?  Illinois Jacquet?  Live, so maybe JATP?

Yes to Things Ain't. Not Jacquet, not JATP.

4. All the Things You Are.  Something about the opening made me think of Ira Sullivan.

Not Ira. The trumpeter is an artist I did not expect to hear with the leader.

5. Guitar and tenor featured prominently.
6. Nice greasy bassline.  Is it Things Ain't What They Used to Be?

Correct.

7. Fast bebop.  Jaws and Griff?

YES! Though the tune is ID'd more as swing.

8. Is this Who Can I Turn to?  Nice gruff tenor, but maybe not as gruff as Ben Webster, so maybe a good time to guess Percy France.

I did mention above Percy does not make an appearance this year.

9.  All the Things You are slowed down to ballad pace on a clarinet.  Buddy DeFranco?

Not Buddy DeFranco.  Not as well known.

10. Average White Band?  Nah, too long for a radio band.  An enjoyable piece of R&B played by capable jazz players.

 

Glad you enjoyed the selections Randy and Happy New Year!