Nonaah won Record of the Year award in the Down Beat Critics Poll in 1978. More accurately, 5 recordings tied for the top spot: Akiyoshi/Tabackin Insights, Ornette’s Dancing In Your Head, Dexter’s Homecoming and Sophisticated Giant, and Nonaah. Reviews almost everywhere were more than positive and the recording did very well in the sales dept. The record has a wonderful “underground” reputation today and is one of the recordings for which I am really proud.
BUT, a warning follows.
This is really tough music. If your primary knowledge of Roscoe’s music is Snurdy McGurdy you may be turned off by the power of these pieces. I have been trying to figure out a way to express this and decided the best way is to post a review written by Rafi Zabor in Musician magazine at the time. Here it is.
This is some of the most uncompromising music I have ever heard. On this recording the Art Ensemble’s tallest altoist obsesses himself with repetition and expansion. On one of the several versions of the title tune he plays a festival audience to a standstill with seven or eight minutes of one thorny phrase. There’s something unnerving about it, like a man blowing up the railroads. There is a variety of music and instrumentation on this double set, though half of it is solo saxophone. Beyond mere anger and modernism, this is flesh.
The only quibble I have with the review is the word anger. Back in the day there was an automatic reaction to forcefulness as anger.