“ the place where hits happened always happened” !
For the rest, just seems to me that’s a reasonable generalisation in the context of a book review, although ‘huge hits’ seems to be an over-the-top of what hapened with Manne/Previn and the follow-ups (did we mention Peterson).
I don’t go to New Yorker for my history, find it to be mostly naively over-written guff even where the material covered is worth knowing about, and have noted Gopnik’s name there. Maybe he looms large for you, just a page-filler for me. Those cartoons would look wrong if they weren’t surrounded by print.
re. the writing of history, that’s never going to be a straight line. And journalism is a significant object of study in any history, so.
PS I tried to find sales figures for the Manne album and can’t, not even a standalone let alone in period context compared to popular/jazz sales.