And how is this any better or worse than downloading the music? The CD has already been bought from the record company by someone, or in many cases it's a promo copy and was given to someone (I buy a lot of those). Buying it used puts nothing into the record company's pockets. It only puts money into the used CD store.
And how is downloading a song any different than what I did as a kid, before I had a job and thus money to buy a CD or tape, which was listen to the radio and tape all my favorite songs when they came on? I had tapes upon tapes upon tapes of songs and never bought a record until I was about 16.
Anyone who truly cares about music will buy the disc. I love having a physical disc with the packaging and the liner notes and the "real" CD and the whole shebang. And AfricaBrass is right, mp3s suck sonically.
But I buy a lot of stuff at the used store. In fact, I bought the Yaya3 record, Larry Golding's new record, Charlie Hunter's new record, and Elastic all from the used CD store about a week after they were released. How is that helping the record companies?
Suing a 12 year old is really heartless. She's doing nothing worse than what I did as a kid with my tape recorder.
I'll say it again. Fuck the RIAA.