He could pull it off, if anyone could.
Agreed, but why would he lower himself to do that? It'd be like Paul and Ringo joining with the original guitar player to reform Herman's Hermits. On the other hand, just showing that he can might be reason enough for Todd. Anybody remember the album side on 'Faithful' where he attempted (pretty successfully, truth be told) to become the Beatles, Dylan, Beach Boys, Yardbirds, and Hendrix on covers of their songs? I listen to 'Back to the Bars' more than any other recording of his, greatly enjoy a lot of the Nazz stuff and the later Todd stuff as well as the classic 70's recordings, and my favorite song by him is "A Dream Goes On Forever", especially the live version. I have a friend who went to high school with Rundgren and tells a really funny story about how he was totally convinced that Rundgren had blown his shot at the big time by quitting his guitar slot in Woody's Truck Stop (one obscure post-Rundgren album on Smash) to start some unknown group called the Nazz. Same friend tells another funny story about expecting the Beatles to fade way quickly as a fad, that he was convinced that the really substantial British Invasion group was the Dave Clark Five.
Don't take any investment tips from that guy.
Yeah, I was actually thinking of that "covers" side of Faithful when I wrote that he could pull it off if anyone could. (His cover of "Good Vibrations" really amazed me at the time.) Why he would want to is an open question...probably just for the sheer hell of it. BTW, the best imitation of the Cars that I've heard in a long, long time has got to be "Stacy's Mom" by Fountains of Wayne.