I'm probably going to cave and get the Goodman despite the alternate tracks...
The Goodwin is good.
I guess that's part of my problem, I don't find O'Day's voice to be sexy.
I don't listen to her mainly for sexiness but because of the high quality of the singing, at least in a jazz context. I think she had a terrific rhythmic sense, and a wonderful grasp of nuance, dynamics, timing, timbre...all that good stuff. Sex appeal is just icing on the cake, although I get that at times, too.