I think that's unfortunate.
Agreed.
I like Yanow's comments, and I like the AMG guide. But SS is correct in his comments. I'm not a musician, but I hear special things in BJP's music that I don't hear anywhere else. I've always been dismayed by what I viewed as Scott's casual reviews of BJP and many other jazz organ dates. It makes me wonder whether he has listened to them more than once.
Scott: please stick around. You do have things to say. SS is very knowledgeable in his area, and I did not detect any personal criticism, or at least nothing that couldn't be worked out through decent dialogue. Yes, Clem can't seem to write a post without putting someone else down, but that's Clem. You already have him on "ignore," right?