I love Tony Bennett, and I love Bill Evans, but this album doesn't do it for me. Evans's playing is gorgeous, but Tony's not in his best voice, IMHO, and he tends to overdo it on a couple of numbers. I think that at a different point in his career this could have been a better record. There are a couple of good tracks, though, including "When in Rome."
I can't stand Gene Lees's lyrics for "Waltz for Debbie." Frankly, I don't care for Lees as either a critic or a lyricist.
I never heard the second Bennett Evans album.