Dude - I'm old enough to recall when there were no playoffs - you either won your league and went to the WS, or else you didn't.
I was more than ok with that, and viewed the whole division/playoff thing with a raised eyebrow. But ok, expansion had made the need for some sort of league-al bifurcation understandable enough. Same thing with the three-division/wildcard split, although..not so much. Give the best-record team a first round bye or some such. The whole "crapshoot" thing bugs me as a guy who likes thrills and all that, but who also believes that bringing too much "chance" into the mix of a championship series changes the meaning of the word "championship". It's like, you can play fairly crappily most of the year and then "get hot" in time to squeak in, and then"stay hot" long enough to "matter", and really, how much arbitrariness is there going to be? Expand the regular season or something...but no $$$ to be had there, at least not as much.
And now, two wild card teams playing one game to see which one will be THE wild card team? I'm kinda like really not into that, not at all. Too much spectacle, and no real; justification for it other than cheap (and cheapening) profit.
TBH, I get the sense that Selig is moving toward a NHL/NBA style playoff system wherein EVERYBODY makes into the playoffs.
Bad for baseball. Bad for purists. Bad for the competition inherent in a 162 game season.
In short [and with my apologies to Steve Winwood and Traffic]: Bug Selig must die.