Well, I haven't read this whole thread yet, and I guess I can understand why someone who was into Clifford Brown and Lee Morgan MIGHT NOT be into Miles. . . . But it's the opposite for me, I love Clifford Brown and Lee Morgan, but I listen to Miles more because he has more to offer ME.
Like Jim I believe that Miles' chops were often superb and he played what he wanted to play. His timing as Jim also mentioned was amazing, a sixth sense that he had. And his leadership abilities were part of his entire musical being. He was a sculptor of sound, and like Elllington a masterful painter of the blues. He was a person who through intimidation, encouragement and perhaps even disdain brought out the very best in those on his payroll. He had a lot of tricks to use to create the architecture he wanted within his sessions.
I put on Miles records to listen to MILES as often as not. I think I always will. I don't even think of him as a trumpet player in a way that I would Brownie or Mogie or Hargrove. I think of him more as just a musician/leader, more as I think of Armstrong in the period I listen to him most (the second half of his career), a consumate thinker and acter on musical ideas and feeling. And I think of Miles as a singer in a way.