I have to confess, I haven't had this problem with enough frequency to even have wanted to develop a strategy, let alone come up with a solution for dealing with it.
I find that the fact that I have been exploring almost all the forks in the jazz road since 1917 means I have plenty of things beckoning me to listen, and I have a collection too large to manage with always something to hear thats new or to listen to again . . . .
I guess I'll continue to count my blessings. B)