Jump to content

Porgy and Bess


mgraham333

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 61
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

The Miles Davis/Gil Evans and the Bill Potts are both essential and they both belong in any respectable jazz collection, but the Mundell Lowe mentioned by JohnS is in the same league. How could you go wrong with Art Farmer and Ben Webster? And Tony Scott's great here on baritone as well. This was an RCA Camden budget LP which, unfortunately, seems to have been completely forgotten.

(Well, almost.)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The Miles Davis/Gil Evans and the Bill Potts are both essential and they both belong in any respectable jazz collection, but the Mundell Lowe mentioned by JohnS is in the same league. How could you go wrong with Art Farmer and Ben Webster? And Tony Scott's great here on baritone as well. This was an RCA Camden budget LP which, unfortunately, seems to have been completely forgotten.

(Well, almost.)

I had to borrow the LP from a historian/professor here at IU, who hipped me to the album. Hopefully it will emerge on CD some day.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The Miles Davis/Gil Evans and the Bill Potts are both essential and they both belong in any respectable jazz collection, but the Mundell Lowe mentioned by JohnS is in the same league. How could you go wrong with Art Farmer and Ben Webster? And Tony Scott's great here on baritone as well. This was an RCA Camden budget LP which, unfortunately, seems to have been completely forgotten.

(Well, almost.)

I had to borrow the LP from a historian/professor here at IU, who hipped me to the album. Hopefully it will emerge on CD some day.

I picked up that RCA Camden version at Stereo Jack's back in June. :tup:tup

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The Miles Davis/Gil Evans and the Bill Potts are both essential and they both belong in any respectable jazz collection, but the Mundell Lowe mentioned by JohnS is in the same league. How could you go wrong with Art Farmer and Ben Webster? And Tony Scott's great here on baritone as well. This was an RCA Camden budget LP which, unfortunately, seems to have been completely forgotten.

(Well, almost.)

I had to borrow the LP from a historian/professor here at IU, who hipped me to the album. Hopefully it will emerge on CD some day.

I picked up that RCA Camden version at Stereo Jack's back in June. :tup:tup

That's pretty ironic--Stereojack is buds w/the professor/historian I borrowed the LP from.

As for favorite version, after listening to a bunch of them, Miles/Gil still just barely noses out the Bill Potts for me.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

As Stewart-Williams & Co., Rex Stewart and Cootie Williams co-led an interesting cast on a 1959 Warner Bros. album called "Porgy and Bess Revisited."

h625.jpg

It is an instrumental album on which roles are assigned to different players. The cast: Cootie Williams (Porgy); Rex Stewart (Sportin' Life); Hilton Jefferson (Bess); Pinky Williams (Jake); Lawrence Brown (Serena and Clara); and a splendid supporting cast that included Barry Galbraith, Ernie Royal, Buddy Weed, Urbie Green, and Sonny Russo.

The album was arranged and conducted by Jim Timmens, who gave a similar treatment to "Show Boat" and Gilbert and Sullivan.

Please excuse me if this album has already been mentioned.

Edited by Christiern
Link to comment
Share on other sites

That's pretty ironic--Stereojack is buds w/the professor/historian I borrowed the LP from.

Another one I like a lot is by Jim Cullum's Jazz Band (Columbia) - they give the score a dixieland interpretation, and it works quite well.

Of course, the Ella/Louis and the Miles/Gil are tops in my book.

Who is that professor/historian?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

That's pretty ironic--Stereojack is buds w/the professor/historian I borrowed the LP from.

Another one I like a lot is by Jim Cullum's Jazz Band (Columbia) - they give the score a dixieland interpretation, and it works quite well.

Of course, the Ella/Louis and the Miles/Gil are tops in my book.

Who is that professor/historian?

Ghost: Although too late for your period of focus, there's a very nice version by the duo of Roland Hanna and George Mraz.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

That's pretty ironic--Stereojack is buds w/the professor/historian I borrowed the LP from.

Another one I like a lot is by Jim Cullum's Jazz Band (Columbia) - they give the score a dixieland interpretation, and it works quite well.

Of course, the Ella/Louis and the Miles/Gil are tops in my book.

Who is that professor/historian?

Michael McGerr.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

That's pretty ironic--Stereojack is buds w/the professor/historian I borrowed the LP from.

Another one I like a lot is by Jim Cullum's Jazz Band (Columbia) - they give the score a dixieland interpretation, and it works quite well.

Of course, the Ella/Louis and the Miles/Gil are tops in my book.

Who is that professor/historian?

I'll second the Jim Cullum interpretation. I wouldn't call it dixieland; it's more planned than that, but it's clearly an interpretation based on pre-30s jazz styles. Too bad it's out of print and damned difficult to find: it deserves better.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The Miles Davis/Gil Evans and the Bill Potts are both essential and they both belong in any respectable jazz collection, but the Mundell Lowe mentioned by JohnS is in the same league. How could you go wrong with Art Farmer and Ben Webster? And Tony Scott's great here on baritone as well. This was an RCA Camden budget LP which, unfortunately, seems to have been completely forgotten.

(Well, almost.)

I had to borrow the LP from a historian/professor here at IU, who hipped me to the album. Hopefully it will emerge on CD some day.

I picked up that RCA Camden version at Stereo Jack's back in June. :tup:tup

That's pretty ironic--Stereojack is buds w/the professor/historian I borrowed the LP from.

As for favorite version, after listening to a bunch of them, Miles/Gil still just barely noses out the Bill Potts for me.

After three listens, I, too, would put the Mundell Lowe right up there in the same league as Miles/Gil and Bill Potts.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Working on the Night Lights show and came across this passage in Miles' autobiography:

Around this time, Columbia wanted Gil and me to do a jazz version of the music from the film Doctor Doolittle.  See, Porgy and Bess had been my best-selling album, and so some real dumb motherfucker over there thought that this Doctor Doolittle would be a great seller.  After listening to that shit I said, "No way, Jose."

:D

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Found it--Michael Denning references a 1935 New Theatre interview with Ellington in THE CULTURAL FRONT (a fantastic book, btw):

In 1935, Ellington criticized Gershwin's Porgy & Bess in an interview with the left-wing New Theatre; after arguing that Porgy & Bess did "not use the Negro musical idiom," Ellington pointed to his own short musical film, Symphony in Black, as an example of a socially critical musical play:  "I put into the dirge all the misery, sorrow and undertones of the conditions that went with the baby's death.  It was true to and of the life of the people it depicted.  The same thing cannot be said for Porgy and Bess."

Denning also quotes Ellington in the same interview as saying, "Grand music and a swell play, but the two don't go together... the music did not hitch with the mood and spirit of the story." Denning posits that Jump for Joy was in some ways a response to Porgy & Bess.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

More seditious comments from Duke. . . . :cool:

Hard to tell if he REALLY felt that way, or if it behooved him to say so. And he's probably right, from his viewpoint as a composer and a chronicler of "my people." And P and B may have been far less a success if it were more as Duke would have had it.

I personally feel that the opera is a masterwork, I like it in its original form very much. But then again, I have a TOTALLY different background and viewpoint from Duke! And. . . my dad instilled a reverence for Gershwin in me by osmosis that I didn't even really realize I had for a long time.

Edited by jazzbo
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think some of Duke's criticism may have stemmed from how under and ill-represented the African-American experience still was on stage in the mid-1930s (and even black musical theater, which had had a run of sorts in the 1920s, was very much on the wane when P & B came out). Even though P & B met with very mixed reviews when it debuted in 1935, it still got a lot of attention, owing to Gershwin's authorship of the music... I wonder if Duke was somewhat resentful that Symphony in Black went so little noticed by comparison.

Gershwin did go down to the Charleston/South Sea Islands area to spend some time in 1934 as he worked on the opera, and from most, if not all, accounts, he was welcomed into the musical church community, first as an observer, and then as a participant.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I go back and forth on this -- in part because I'm not normally a fan of this conductor and also because I've heard that cast members were unhappy with his rather know-it-all manner both in the recording session and the Glyndebourne production that preceded it -- but for the opera itself I'm very impressed by Simon Rattle's recording, which essentially turns "P&B" into a somewhat different work by emphasizing the harsher, more modernist aspects of the score (i.e. in the orchestra's contribution). Rather than being there more or less to accompany the singers, the orchestra is transformed in this recording into a semi-independent force -- a kind of Fate Machine is how it hits me. My guess is that, consciously or not, Rattle had in mind as a model here the role that Kurt Weill's music plays in the Brecht-Weill works. Whatever, it makes for a different "P&B" in dramatic terms and one that arguably fits the conclusion of the story quite well.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.

×
×
  • Create New...