I totally missed what was so great about the Replacements ... I thought they were a good band, but didn't think they stood out in a historical context, if you will. I have to wonder if they came up at a different time if they would have gotten the same acclaim.
On the other hand, now I've got that nutty "Dyslexic Heart" tune stuck in my head and I can't make it stop.
You really need to listen to their lyrics. Westerberg's selection of topics, use of double entendres and dark humor, all done tongue-in-cheek are unsurpassed IMHO. Just listen to songs like Answering Machine, Swinging Party, Androgynous, I Will Dare, Sixteen Blue, Alex Chilton, etc, etc..