Had a listen to this one last night, & it got better for me the deeper into the disc it got. At first, I was kinda all eyes-rolling "o....k... more Trane shit" (even though as seemingly unanimously noted, Pharoah plays great throughout. But it's not his album....). Just waaaaaay too much gesture from the rhythm section, and Garrett seems more than happy to meet them on their terms rather than bringing them to his. But the further into it got, the less derivative it seemed to get, and my interest perked up accoringly. Maybe they just wore me down.
The voices don't bother me at all. I like voices ok. What did bother me was that too much of it sounded like it should have been a Strata-East side of 30+ years ago. C'mon, that shit was great then, but I know how it goes already, and have for quite a while. Give it a twist. Or something.
If I'd not already heard a lot of what this album was modeled on, I'd probably go apeshit & give it rave reviews. In DownBeat language, that's 5 stars. Knowing what I know, I'd give it 3 stars, just because no matter how good it is, and it's quite good, there's still a lingering sense that no matter how "intense" it is, it's more the intensity of effort rather than discovery. To be as objective as possible (and because Pharoah plays really, really beautifully from start to finish), I'll split the difference & give it 4.