Joe

I am very fond of the "comeback" BNs as well. I give the slight edge to BUT NOT FAREWELL for mood. But ETERNAL SPIRIT contains some of Hill's most bright and joyous music. I used to be a bit cool on POINT OF DEPARTURE, but I've grown to admire it more over the last couple of years. I think DIVINE REVELATION might be his most underrated record.

My first Hill and still among my favorites. And, if we are talking sideman appearances...

Was lucky enough to meet (and occasionally visit with) Mr. Golia during my time at CalArts. He still teaches there. https://music.calarts.edu/programs-specializations/jazz/faculty/vinny-golia SFUMATO on Clean Feed is excellent. Also, any date that pairs him with or features Rob Blakeslee is worth hearing. SPIRIT OF THE TIMES, LONG NARROWS... Rob is a fantastic trumpet player in his own right.

I will have to ask my printer friends about the litho/lino thing, but they're too stoned right now to be of much help. Jim, I think you will be surprised at the accuracy of some of your guesses! Track 1: not Shafi Hadi, but a figure not unilke him. I do wish there were more Shafi Hadi to hear. Dude was deep. I have listened to track 10 a lot lately. The whole LP, in fact. "Guilty pleasure" maybe. Not sure why this one affects me the way it does. I think you may have finally articulated it for me. Just typed up my "reveal" notes today. All will etc. 10/1. Much grass!

Ye, a superb LP. Not issued until the 80's, correct?

Most overlooked classic-era BN sesh? Most overlooked classic-era 2-tenor date? (There's also the Rouse-Quinichette date for Bethlehem, and the Booker Ervin-Bill Barron HOT LINE.)

One of my all-time faves. What a musician; what a life!

All great music!

Thanks! Pretty sure everyone has IDed the tune on #1. #7 is going to be a big stretch for some listeners. Glad you dug it! #9 might be based on a standard. But, to the bet of my knowledge, it is an original/contrafact. #12, not Duke, but there's a conceptual connection (?). #13: I think some folks have IDed the other horn, but no one has drawn a bull's eye on the trumpet player. Let's just say those two soloists have a history together. Ha! Not the Grubbs Bros., but those Visitors records are great sources for BFT tracks. Ditto the Catalyst stuff, to keep things Philly-centric for a moment.

Nice! https://fromthestacks.bandcamp.com/album/garganos-garage-lavender-magenta-indigo-blue-fin-labels << As we began to transfer the reels and sift through the paper, the picture got fuzzier. Vic Gargano had multiple labels: Inferno, Indigo, Magenta, Lavender, Invicta, Condor, and Blue Fin, and an equal amount of silent partners. By nearly every account of the artists we spoke with, there was most certainly a criminal element in the background, but few were willing to go on record. “We were in the middle of a session and these guys showed up,” said an off-the-record source. “Vic went outside with them and came back ten minutes later with blood all over his face. He walked into the recording booth and said, ‘Back to work’ like nothing had happened at all.” >>

Reading through those comments, I kept thinking about Ellison's "battle in the bucket of crabs" (from INVISIBLE MAN). Ironic, given how much Crouch worshipped Ellison. But he could not see — more likely, IMO, chose to ignore/compartmentalize/rationalize — his own trollish tendencies.

Arranged by Gil Evans!

I mean, it all depends on who you are and where you come from. My formal jazz education, such as it was, was anything but Kenton-centric. This was in the early 90's. My teacher — a good one, IMO — was always conscientious about placing the music in a sociopolitical context and foregrounding the Black men and women who made lasting aesthetic contributions. I think the key word here is "institutional." As Everson points out early in his write-up, the living, breathing history of the music never really happened in institutions, at least not until the 70's. Crouch was a complicated man who leaves a complicated legacy. And I agree: had he continued to pursue the same rhetorical strategies that brought him fame/infamy in his heyday in the era of social media, his legacy might be even more complicated.

The pugilist is now at rest.

Thanks! Looking forward to reading your thoughts/impressions!

Yes, this is great stuff. Kind of a more energetic GNU HIGH.

I forgot about that one! Thanks!

Thank you for these comments! #4 I chose precisely because I have played this performance for friends before and they have also heard Corea and Jarrett in it. But it's not Chick or Keith. I don't believe 11 has ever made it to CD, FWIW. But maybe in Japan?

I don't disagree. But I also don't think WE INSIST is really talking about or focused on the music at all. Which, come to think of it, is pretty Crouch-ian/Albert Murray-esque/Wynton-y.

Well, I wasn't really thinking so much about the music industry (shudder) as I was about a broader context in which WE INSIST's "demands" exist. Reparations has become a pretty big tent — conceptually speaking — as this recent report by the Brookings Institution indicates. https://www.brookings.edu/policy2020/bigideas/why-we-need-reparations-for-black-americans/ Also, I get it... the "create alternatives" argument can sound like a kindler, gentler rendition of the "bootstrapping" argument. Still patrician. But I think we need to have better conversations about agency, period.