It's been a long time since I comnpared them, but my memory is that I prefered the remakes on all but one where I strongly prefered the original. FWIW, YMMV, etc. Interesting that Bob bothered to do that, he's generally one take or less....
Supposedly he was visiting his brother who heard the original takes and thought they revealed too much about his marriage. Though that wouldn't account for all the remakes.