Much of this seems to be rationalization and cheap politics. One can find examples of anything and everything to excuse anything and everything. I'm sorry Rod but if stealing from Elmo Hope is bad and stealing from someone who pays money to Elmo Hope is (maybe) ok, where do you draw the friggin' line and who gave you that power?
I'm much more interested in what is "right" than what's "legal" but under the current system the only chance to get what is "right" is to use the legal system. Sadly that costs more than most of the "victims" can afford and they just lose. As Alexander has demonstrated, this does seem to be a "generational thing" and that scares the shit out of me. It is bad enough the world is in creative doldrums but to have the potential audience think the product is their "right" is really scary.