Oh, come on Steve,
I share your enthusiasm for all those and own plenty of albums by them but also like Akinmusire too and have four of his/albums. Not necessarily a case of either/or for me.
There's a buzz because he is a talented musician, no one on this thread has questioned that. We're just discussing the progression or otherwise of his recording career to date.
Whales swimming in shoals
, lovely description. But I do read the Guardian music pages (lees than I used to), am I a "cool aunt"?