Tom,
While this may seem like a longshot, it may be worth a try. If your liberal arts college has a career center, chances are that they can help you design a really nice resume and provide you with counselling for career options.
I know the University of Toronto (which I am graduating from this year) provides both students and alumni with this service. I'm not sure this is the case with other schools, but if it is, I would definately take them up on it as they often provide really good advice and, in some cases, contacts.