To me this is mainstream music with no edge, just enough "quirk" to apply to the beard + glasses set, but rhythmically dull and tonally like soppy milquetoast. Contemporary jazz in this vein all sounds pretty much identical; yeah, sure Melford and Knuffke are strong voices on their own, but not used to any effect whatsoever here. It could be almost any New School grad on piano and cornet and I would not know the difference. The Pi set is a little more herky-jerky and obviously there are some excellent releases and artists within the subgenre (Halvorson, Bynum, Shyu, et al.) but in that case I feel that a good chunk of the vibe is keyed into the aging post-rocker who's outgrown the first three or four Tortoise records and needs something else. I was in the same place at one point but veered towards the charred earth instead of the button down set.
Anyway, back to the tune at hand. Miller's drumming is just awful. I have heard her play with more fire and inventiveness, sorta, but this is unlistenable.
Re: the politics: give me Irreversible Entanglements over this shit any day of the week.