I first saw Redman when he had a band with Metheny, Billy Higgins and Charlie Haden. I was very underwhelmed.
Since then, he's produced some entertaining, and in some cases, fine music, but he's no 'force' or innovator.
His new band has Reuben Rogers, who I really like a lot.
I'll take McCaslin over most tenors today. US tenors, that is.